Appendix

Merrimack Valley Metropolitan Planning

Organization

Federal Fiscal Years 2023 to 2027

Transportation Improvement Program

Appendix Final Report

May 2022

Prepared by the Merrimack Valley Planning Commission

This document was prepared in cooperation with the Massachusetts Department of
Transportation and the U.S. Department of Transportation. (under Contract
# 114679 with MassDOT) The views and opinions of the Merrimack Valley Planning Commission expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the Massachusetts Department of Transportation or the U.S. Department of Transportation.
Page intentionally left blank.

Table of Contents

Appendices......................................................................................................................... 1
Appendix A Other Regional Priority Bridge Projects ........................................................... 2
Appendix B Other Regional Priority Roadway Projects ...................................................... 3
Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary................................................... 5
Appendix D Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet .......................................................... 10
Appendix E Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Tracking ................................................................. 15
FFYs 2023 to 2027 Projects GHG Tracking Summary 21
Appendix F Completed Highway and Transit Projects GHG Summary ............................ 57
Appendix G List of Acronyms ........................................................................................... 67
Appendix H Key to Maps Showing Locations of Transportation Projects ......................... 74
Appendix I Comments Received on Draft TIP .................................................................. 77
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022

Appendices

Appendix A and B: Other Regional Priorities

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 1

Appendix A Other Regional Priority Bridge Projects

(No Funding Available)

Bridges That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets,

and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town):

ID

Location

Project Description

Estimated Total Project Cost

602322

Ames.

Amesbury - Bridge Replacement,

A-07-008, Oak Street Over the B&M Railroad

(Abandoned Line)

$1,000,000

And.

Andover - Rehab. Bridge (A-09-001) Route 28 (North Main Street) Over the Shawsheen

River

605418

And.

Andover - Bridge Preservation,

A-09-028, Chandler Road over I-93

$3,450,000

604839

Law.

Lawrence – Bridge Replacement,

L-04-027, Lowell Street over B&M Railroad

$4,473,000

Law.

Lawrence - Bridge Rehabilitation,

L-04-042, South Union Connector over South

Street

Nbypt.

Newburyport - Bridge (N-11-002) State Route

113 (High Street) Over Railroad

Nbypt.

Newburyport - Bridge (N-11-014) State Route

1A (High Street) over US 1

607115

Nbypt.

Newburyport - Bridge Repairs,

N-11-015, Washington St. over US 1

$1,400,000

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 2

Appendix B Other Regional Priority Roadway Projects

(No Funding Available)

Roadway Projects That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets, and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town)

ID

Location

Project Description

Estimated Total Project Cost

611957

Andover

Andover– Reconstruction on Route 133 (Lowell Street), from Shawsheen Road to Route 28 (North Main Street) TEC = 12.03

$10,080,306

606721

Boxford

Boxford- Reconstruction of Route 133 (Washington Street) from North Andover town line to Main Street TEC = 5.65

$5,172,164

Boxford

Boxford Reconstruction of Route 97 from

Georgetown to Topsfield (2 miles)

$3,785,000

607540

Boxford

Boxford - Border to Boston Trail

TEC = 4.35

$4,174,500

602843

Georgetown

Georgetown – Reconstruction on Route 97 (W. Main Street) from Moulton Street to Groveland T.L. TEC = 9.03

$6,662,599

Haverhill

Haverhill -Intersection Improvements Route

110 and Elliott Street

Haverhill

Haverhill – Widen Route 97 (Broadway)

from Computer Drive to Research Drive

608721

Haverhill

Haverhill – Corridor Improvements on Water Street (Route 97/113), from Ginty Boule- vard/Mill Street to Lincoln Boulevard/River- side Avenue TEC = 9.35

$8,050,000

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 3

Appendix B Other Regional Priority Roadway Projects (Continued) (No Funding Available)

Roadway Projects That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets,

and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town):

ID

Location

Project Description

Estimated Total Project Cost

602339

Haverhill

Haverhill-Historic Waterfront Walkway Phase II (Construction)

$3,110,184

Lawrence/ North Andover

Lawrence - North Andover - Reconstruction of Route 114 from I-495 in Lawrence to Waverly Road in North Andover TEC = 12.70

Lawrence

Lawrence – Corridor Improvements on Broad- way (Route 28) from Water Street/ Canal Street to Haverhill Street (Route 110)

Newbury- port

Newburyport -Route 1 Rotary Reconfiguration

North

Andover

North Andover – Reconstruction of Mass. Ave. and Sidewalks (from Osgood St. to I-495)

North

Andover

North Andover - Signals and turn lanes at

Mass Ave. and I-495 NB and SB Ramps

607710

Salisbury

Salisbury – Resurfacing and related work

Route 1A TEC = 7.98.

$2,300,000

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 4

Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 5

Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary

Programmed for Fund- ing in TIP

ID#

Project Description

Project

Cost in

1000s

AADT

Linear Lane Miles

Condition

Mobility

Safety & Security

Community Effects & Support

Land Use & Economic

Development

Environmental Effects

Total TEC Score (2023-

2027)

No

Lawrence –North Andover - Reconstruction of Rt. 114 from I-495 to Rt. 125 (Ando- ver St.)

30,000

5.6

2.50

3.00

2.00

2.20

2.25

0.75

12.70

Yes

608095

North Andover– Corridor Im- provements on Route 114, between Waverly Road & Willow/Mill Street

$32,773

30,000

4.8

2.00

2.75

2.67

2.00

2.25

0.75

12.42

No

611957

Andover – Reconstruction of Rt. 133 (Lowell Street) from Shawsheen Road to Route

28 (North Main Street)

$10,080

12,773

2.3

2.50

2.75

2.33

1.20

1.75

1.50

12.03

Yes

602202

Salisbury – Reconstruction of Rt. 1 (Lafayette Road)

$17,514

12,147

4.8

2.50

2.50

2.67

0.80

2.5

0.75

11.72

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 6

Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary (Cont.)

Programmed for Fund- ing in TIP

ID#

Project Description

Project

Cost in

1000s

AADT

Linear Lane Miles

Condition

Mobility

Safety & Security

Community Effects & Support

Land Use & Economic

Development

Environmental Effects

Total TEC Score (2023-

2027)

Yes

610924

Lawrence – Roadway Re- construction on Amesbury Street

$7,720

16,446

1.5

2.00

2.25

2.00

2.40

2.25

0.25

11.15

No

608721

Haverhill - Corridor Im- provements on Water St. from Ginty Blvd / Mill St. to Lincoln Ave./ Riverside Ave.

$8,050

20,200

2.0

2.00

1.75

2.00

1.60

1.75

1.00

10.10

No

602843

Georgetown – Reconstruc- tion on Route 97 (W. Main) from Moulton St. to Groveland TL

$7,567

15,486

2.2

1.50

1.25

1.33

1.20

1.75

2.00

9.03

Yes

608788

Haverhill - Reconstruction of North Ave. from Main St. to NH state line

$20,346

13,172

4.0

2.50

2.00

1.33

2.00

0.00

0.75

8.58

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 7

Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary (Cont.)

Programmed for Fund- ing in TIP

ID#

Project Description

Project

Cost in

1000s

AADT

Linear Lane Miles

Condition

Mobility

Safety & Security

Community Effects & Support

Land Use & Economic

Development

Environmental Effects

Total TEC Score (2023-

2027)

Yes

608029

Newburyport – Intersection Improvements Rt. 1 at Merri- mac St.

$2,475

24,850

NA

2.00

0.50

2.67

1.20

1.25

0.75

8.37

No

Salisbury – Reconstruction of

Route 1A

5,356

4.1

3.00

1.25

1.33

0.40

1.25

0.75

7.98

Yes

610658

Methuen - Intersection Im- provements at Riverside Drive and Burnham Road

$1,924

NA

NA

2.00

1.25

1.67

2.20

0.50

0.25

7.87

Yes

607541

Georgetown- Boxford– Border to Boston Trail, from Georgetown Road to West Main Street (Route 97)

$2,423

NA

NA

1.00

1.75

1.00

1.20

2.00

0.25

7.20

Yes

611977

Amesbury – Riverwalk Con- nector to the Salisbury Point Ghost Trail

$2,111

NA

NA

0.00

1.50

1.00

1.6

2.25

0.50

6.85

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 8

Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary (Cont.)

Programmed for Fund- ing in TIP

ID#

Project Description

Project

Cost in

1000s

AADT

Linear Lane Miles

Condition

Mobility

Safety & Security

Community Effects & Support

Land Use & Economic

Development

Environmental Effects

Total TEC Score (2023-

2027)

Yes

607542

Georgetown– Newbury – Bor- der to Boston Trail (Northern Georgetown to Byfield Sec- tion)

$6,070

NA

NA

1.00

1.25

0.67

1.40

2.00

0.50

6.82

Yes

609392

Rowley – Safety Improve- ments at Route 1, Central and Glen Streets

$1,331

NA

NA

1.50

1.25

2.00

1.00

0.25

0.50

6.50

No

606721

Boxford - Route 133 (North

Andover TL to Main St.)

$5,172

6,149

2.9

1.50

1.00

1.00

0.40

0.50

1.25

5.65

No

607540

Boxford – section of Border to

Boston Trail

$4,175

NA

NA

0.50

1.25

1.00

0.60

0.50

0.50

4.35

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 9

Appendix D Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 10

Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet

Merrimack Valley Planning Commission and MassDOT Evaluation Criteria

Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Shawsheen Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 611957

Project Cost: $10,080,305 AADT: 12,773 Distance: 1.17 Linear Lane Miles: 2.34

Condition

Score

Additional Comments

A. Magnitude of pavement condition improvement.

2

PNF indicates longitudinal & lateral pavement cracking, utility patch failure, shoving and rutting of pavement along route.

B. Magnitude of improvement of other infrastructure.

3

Sidewalk one side. 10’ Shared Use Path with 5’ buffer on other side for bicycles and > safety for pedestrians, upgrade signals, drainage improvements

Condition Average

2.5

Mobility

Score

Additional Comments

A. Effect on magnitude and duration of congestion.

3

Project includes Shawsheen Square as well.

B. Effect on travel time and connectivity / access.

2

New Shared Use Path

C. Effect on other modes using the facility.

3

New shared use path, sidewalks on both sides.

D. Effect on regional and local traffic.

3

Widening shoulder, adding left turn lanes, Additional connector I-495 to I-93. NHS roadway.

Mobility Average

2.75

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 11

Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)

Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Shawsheen Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 611957

Safety and Security

Score

Additional Comments

A. Effect on crash rate compared to State average.

3

Rt 28 and 133 is HSIP crash cluster, crash rate = 1.75, And arterial between the two signalized intersections is

3.8, State Avg. = 2.12.

B. Effect on bicycle and pedestrian safety.

3

Shared Use Path and extra sidewalk, shoulder for bicy- cles, and provides greater safety for bicycles and pe- destrians.

C. Effect on transportation security and evacuation routes/

1

Is an NHS roadway.

Is an evacuation route.

Safety and Security Average

2.33

Community Effects and Support

Score

Additional Comments

A. Residential effects: ROW, noise, aesthetics, cut through traffic, and other.

2

May need easements for retaining wall. For the most part all within ROW. General appearance and less noise from better pavement conditions.

B. Public, local government, legislative, and regional sup- port.

3

Letter of support from Sen. Finegold

C. Effect on service to minority or low-income neighbor- hoods. (Title VI and EJ)

0

Not Title VI or EJ area.

D. Other impacts / benefits to minority or low-income neighborhoods. (Title VI and EJ).

0

Not Title VI or EJ area.

E. Effect on development and redevelopment of housing

1

Community Effects and Support Average

1.20

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 12

Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)

Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Shawsheen Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 611957

Land Use and Economic Development

Score

Additional Comments

A. Business effects; ROW, noise, traffic, parking, freight access, other.

2

Improve access to existing businesses.

B. Sustainable development effects. Consistent with

MVPGS.

2

Access to MVPGS Brickstone Square State PDA. Improves transportation choice (walk/bike) for area resi- dents.

C. Consistent with regional land-use and economic devel- opment plans and PGS.

2

Access to MVPGS Brickstone Square State PDA. Improves transportation choice (walk/bike) for area resi- dents.

D. Effect on job creation.

1

Should provide better access to Brickstone Square

State PDA.

Land Use and Economic Development Average

1.75

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 13

Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)

Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Shawsheen Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 611957

Environmental Effects

Score

Additional Comments

A. Air quality / Climate effects. GHG Impact Description – Assumed Nominal Decrease in Emissions from Other Improvements

2

Shared Use Path and sidewalks. Reduced delays at intersections.

B. Water quality/supply effects; wetlands effects.

1

There will be deep sump catch basins

C. Historic and cultural resources effects.

3

Shawsheen Village Historic District

D. Effect on wildlife habitat and endangered species.

0

Not endangered species habitat area.

Environmental Effects Average

1.5

Overall Project TEC score

12.03

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 14

Appendix E Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Tracking

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 15

2023 to 2027

Transportation Improvement Program

Greenhouse Gas Tracking

This section summarizes the greenhouse gas (GHG) impacts that are anticipated to result from the projects that are included in this FFY 2023 to 2027 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP). It includes a summary of the state laws and policies that call for reducing greenhouse gas in order to mitigate global climate change, actions that respond to these state laws and policies, the role of regional planning and TIP development in reducing GHG emission and tracking these reductions, and the projected GHG emission impacts from the projects programmed in the TIP.

State Policy Context

The Global Warming Solutions Act (GWSA), which was signed into law in August 2008, makes Massachusetts a leader in setting aggressive and enforceable GHG reduction targets, and implementing policies and initiatives to achieve these targets. In keeping with the law, on December 29, 2010 the Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs (EOEEA), in consultation with other state agencies and the public, released the Massachusetts Clean Energy and Climate Plan for 2020. In December 2014 the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) issued new regulations that require Metropolitan Planning Organizations to quantify impacts from project investments, track progress towards reductions, and consider impacts in the prioritization of project investments. The targets for overall statewide GHG emissions are:

By 2020: 25 percent reduction below statewide 1990 GHG emission levels, and

By 2050: 80 percent reduction below statewide 1990 GHG emission levels

The Role of Metropolitan Planning Organizations

The Commonwealth’s MPOs are integrally involved in supporting the GHG reductions mandated under the GWSA. The MPOs are most directly involved in helping to achieve the GHG emissions reductions through the promotion of healthy transportation modes through prioritizing and programming an appropriate balance of roadway, transit, bicycle and pedestrian investments – and assisting smart growth development patterns through the creation of a balanced multi-modal transportation system. This is realized through the transportation goals and policies espoused in the Regional Transportation Plans (RTPs),
the major projects planned in the RTPs, and the mix of new transportation projects that are programmed and implemented through the TIPs. GHG tracking and evaluation processes enable the MPOs to identify the anticipated GHG impacts of planned and programmed
projects, and also to use GHG impacts as a criterion in prioritizing transportation projects.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 16

Project-Level GHG Tracking and Evaluation in TIPs

It is also important to monitor and evaluate the GHG impacts of the transportation projects that are programmed in the MPOs’ TIPs. The TIPs include both the larger, regionally- significant projects from the RTPs, which are reported in the Statewide GHG report, as well as smaller projects that are not included in the RTP but that may nevertheless have
impacts on GHG emissions. The primary objective of this tracking is to enable the MPOs to evaluate expected GHG impacts of different projects and to use this information as a criterion for prioritizing and programming projects.

Calculation of GHG Impacts for TIP Projects

MassDOT has adopted spreadsheets used by MPOs to determine CMAQ eligibility and that also include CO2 impacts. The data and analysis required for these calculations is available from functional design reports that are submitted for projects that would produce a measurable GHG impact.

Projects with Quantified Impacts

RTP Projects

Major capacity expansion projects are expected to have a significant impact on GHG emissions. These projects are included in each MPO’s RTP and analyzed using either the statewide model or Boston MPO’s regional model, which reflect GHG impacts. As a result, no independent TIP calculations are required.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions

For those projects that are expected to produce a measurable decrease in emissions, the approach for calculating these impacts is described below. These projects are categorized in the following manner:

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement - An intersection reconstruction or signalization project that is projected to reduce delay and congestion.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Pedestrian and Bicycle Infrastructure - A shared-use path that enables increased walking and biking and decreased vehicle-miles traveled (VMT).

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from New/Additional Transit Service - A bus or shuttle service that enables increased transit ridership and decreased VMT.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from a Park and Ride Lot - A park-and- ride lot that enables increased transit ridership/ increased ridesharing and

decreased VMT.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 17

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

A bus replacement that directly reduces GHG emissions generated by service.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Complete Streets Improvements - Improvements to roadway networks that include the addition of bicycle and pedestrian accommodations where none were present before.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Alternative Fuel Vehicle Procurements – A vehicle procurement where alternative fuel/ advanced technology vehicles replace traditional gas or diesel vehicles.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Anti-idling Strategies – Implementation of policies such as limiting idling allowed, incorporationg anti- idling technology into fleets and using LED lights on trucks for the purpose of illuminating worksites.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bike Share Projects – A new bike share project or capacity added to existing project.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Induced Travel Projects – A project that changes roadway capacity.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Speed Reduction Programs –

Programs that reduce speed to no less than 55 miles per hour.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Transit Signal Priority Projects – A project that applies this technology to a signal intersection or along a corridor that impacts bus service.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Truck Stop Electrification Projects

A new truck stop electrification project or capacity added to an existing project.

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Other Improvement

Quantified Increase in Emissions

Projects expected to produce a measurable increase in emissions.

Projects with No Assumed Impacts

No Assumed Impact/Negligible Impact on Emissions - Projects that do not change the capacity or use of a facility (e.g. roadway median barrier or retaining wall replacement, or bridge rehabilitation/replacement that restores the bridge to its previous condition) are assumed to have no/negligible GHG impact.

Qualitative Decrease in Emissions

Projects expected to produce a minor decrease in emissions that cannot be calculated with any precision. Examples of such projects include roadway repaving, signage improvement,
ITS improvement, or transit marketing/customer experience improvement.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 18

Qualitative Increase in Emissions

Projects expected to produce a minor increase in emissions that cannot be calculated with any precision.

Regional Greenhouse Gas Impact Summary Tables for FFYs 2023 to

2027 TIP

The following tables summarize the calculated quantitative and assumed qualitative impacts of the projects included in the regional FFYs 2023 to 2027 TIP by year.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 19
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 20

FFYs 2023 to 2027 Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 21

2023 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

606522

ANDOVER- BRIDGE REHABILITATION, A-

09-036, I-495 OVER ST

28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495

OVER B&M AND MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 OVER ST 28 (NB)

$85,115,436

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$173,075,000

AC Yr 1 of 4

602202

SALISBURY- RECONSTRUCTION OF ROUTE 1 (LAFAYETTE ROAD)

$13,293,829

Quantitative

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bi- cycle and Pedestrian Infrastructure

$19,266,283

AC Yr 1 of 2

Quantity of GHG impact is in year 2

609392

ROWLEY – SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS AT ROUTE 1, CENTRAL AND GLEN STREETS

$1,352,139

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,352,139



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 22

2024 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

610658

METHUEN – INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS AT RIVERSIDE DRIVE AND BURNHAM ROAD

$2,063.889

Quantitative

333,725

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement

$2,063.889

608095

NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN WAVERLY ROAD & WILLOW/MILL STREET

$5,432,436

Qualitative

RTP project included in the Statewide model.

$34,083,859

AC Yr 1 of 4

602202

SALISBURY- RECONSTRUCTION OF ROUTE 1 (LAFAYETTE ROAD)

$5,972,454

Quantitative

27,932

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bi- cycle and Pedestrian Infrastructure

$19,266,283

AC Yr 2 of 2



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 23

2024 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

606522

ANDOVER- BRIDGE REHABILITATION, A-09-

036, I-495 OVER ST 28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495

OVER B&M AND MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 OVER ST 28 (NB)

$60,000,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$173,075,000

AC Yr 2 of 4

605304

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

007 & H-12-025, BRIDGE STREET (SR

125) OVER

MERRIMACK RIVER AND THE ABANDONED B&M RR (PROPOSED BIKEWAY)

$20,600,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$108,011,904

AC Yr 1 of 3.


Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 24

2024 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

609466

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

040, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER

$21,388,926

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$96,087,420

AC Yr 1 of 4.

607541

GEORGETOWN- BOXFORD- BORDER TO BOSTON TRAIL, FROM GEORGETOWN ROAD TO WEST MAIN STREET (ROUTE 97)

$2,520,436

Quantitative

2,667

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure

$2,520,436

608930

LAWRENCE- LAWRENCE MANCHESTER RAIL CORRIDOR (LMRC) RAIL TRAIL

$1,000,000

Quantitative

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure

$21,416,304

AC Yr 1 of 2

Quantity of GHG impact is in year 2



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 25

2024 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

610924

LAWRENCE- ROADWAY RECONSTRUCTION ON AMESBURY STREET

$8,028,654

Qualitative

$8,028,654

Not yet enough in- formation to generate an estimate



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 26

2025 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

608095

NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN WAVERLY ROAD & WILLOW/MILL STREET

$13,239,974

Qualitative

RTP project included in the Statewide Model.

$34,083,859

AC Yr 2 of 4

612193

ANDOVER- BRIDGE PRESERVATION, A-09-

022, I-93 OVER

MERRIMACK RIVER

$38,102,400

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$38,102,400

606522

ANDOVER- BRIDGE REHABILITATION, A-

09-036, I-495 OVER ST

28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495

OVER B&M AND MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 OVER ST 28 (NB)

$12,325,976

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$173,075,000

AC Yr 3 of 4



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 27

2025 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

612143

ANDOVER- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, A-09-

015, TEWKSBURY STREET OVER MBTA/BMRR

$17,383,839

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$17,383,839

612045

ANDOVER- TEWKSBURY- INTERSTATE MAINTENANCE AND RELATED WORK ON I-

93

$18,525,197

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$18,525,197

609466

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

040, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER

$39,813,300

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$96,087,420

AC Yr 2 of 4.



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 28

2025 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

605304

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

007 & H-12-025, BRIDGE STREET (SR

125) OVER

MERRIMACK RIVER AND THE ABANDONED B&M RR (PROPOSED BIKEWAY)

$30,900,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$108,011,904

AC Yr 2 of 3.

612002

LAWRENCE – COMMUNITY DAY ARLINGTON IMPROVEMENTS (SRTS)

(# 612002)

$1,554,211

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,554,211



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 29

2025 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

608930

LAWRENCE- LAWRENCE MANCHESTER RAIL CORRIDOR (LMRC) RAIL TRAIL

$20,416,304

Quantitative

175,927

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bi- cycle and Pedestrian Infrastructure

$21,416,304

AC Yr 2 of 2

612158

METHUEN- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, M-17-

026, ROUTE 213

EB/WB OVER THE METHUEN RAIL TRAIL

$4,598,252

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$4,598,252



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 30

2026 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

608095

NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN WAVERLY ROAD & WILLOW/MILL STREET

$12,916,056

Qualitative

RTP project included in the Statewide Model.

$34,083,859

AC Yr 3 of 4

606522

ANDOVER- BRIDGE REHABILITATION, A-

09-036, I-495 OVER ST

28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495

OVER B&M AND MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 OVER ST 28 (NB)

$15,633,589

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$173,075,000

AC Yr 4 of 4



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 31

2026 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

607542

GEORGETOWN- NEWBURY- BORDER TO BOSTON TRAIL, (NORTHERN GEORGETOWN TO BYFIELD SECTION)

$6,798,000

Quantitative

15,682

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure

$6,798,000

S12208

GROVELAND IMPROVEMENTS AT DR. ELMER BAGNALL ELEMENTARY (SRTS)

$1,858,080

Qualitative

Qualitative decrease in emissions

$1,858,080

609466

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

040, I-495 (NB & SB)

OVER MERRIMACK RIVER

$23,692,243

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$96,087,420

AC Yr 3 of 4.



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 32

2026 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

605304

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

007 & H-12-025, BRIDGE STREET (SR

125) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER AND THE ABANDONED B&M RR (PROPOSED BIKEWAY)

$56,511,904

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$108,011,904

AC Yr 3 of 3.

612074

LAWRENCE – BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, L-04-

012, SHORT STREET

OVER SPICKET RIVER

$3,285,005

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$3,285,005



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 33

2027 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional In- formation

611977

AMESBURY- RIVERWALK CONNECTOR TO THE SALISBURY POINT GHOST TRAIL

$2,448,760

Quantitative

195

Quantified de- crease in emis- sions from bi- cycle and pe- destrian infra- structure

$2,448,760

608788

HAVERHILL- ROADWAY RECONSTRUCTION ON NORTH AVENUE, FROM MAIN STREET (ROUTE 125) TO PLAISTOW, NH

$5,798,257

Quantitative

214,372

Quantified De- crease in Emis- sions from Traffic Opera- tional Improve- ment

$23,600,997

AC YR 1 OF 3

608029

NEWBURYPORT- INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS ROUTE 1 & MERRIMAC STREET

$2,870,513

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligi- ble impact on emissions

$2,870,513

Not yet enough infor- mation to gen- erate an esti- mate



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 34

2027 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Additional

Information

608095

NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN WAVERLY ROAD & WILLOW/MILL STREET

$2,495,393

Qualitative

RTP project in- cluded in the Statewide Model.

$34,083,859

AC Yr 4 of 4

609466

HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12-

040, I-495 (NB & SB)

OVER MERRIMACK RIVER

$11,192,951

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligi- ble impact on emissions

$96,087,420

AC Yr 4 of 4.



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 35

2023 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010747

MVRTA Preventative Mainte- nance for Service

$3,730,510

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$3,730,510

RTD0010748

MVRTA Operating Assis- tance for Service

$1,478,730

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,478,730

RTD0010749

MVRTA ADA Paratransit

Service

$1,861,090

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,861,090

RTD0010750

MVRTA Replace 8 Model Yr

2011 35’ buses delivery 2023

4,384,400

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

4,384,400

RTD0010751

MVRTA Replace 6 Model Yr

2017 Type E-2 vans delivery

2023

$469,620

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$469,620



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 36

2023 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010752

MVMPO Short Range Transit

Planning

$100,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$100,000

RTD0010758

MVRTA Replace 1 Model Yr

2017 supervisory vehicle

$50,335

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$50,335

RTD0011300

MVRTA - BUY REPLACEMENT VAN

$469,620

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$469,620

RTD0011301

MVRTA - METROPOLITAN PLANNING

$65,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$65,000

RTD0011304

MVRTA- BUY REPLACEMENTS- CAPITOL BUS

$2,983,200

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$2,983,200

RTD0011305

MVRTA - BUY REPLACEMENTS- CAPITOL BUS

$1,401,200

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$1,401,200



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 37

2023 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0011306

MVRTA- REHAB/ RENOVATE - MISC EQUIPMENT

$1,700,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,700,000

RTD0011307

MVRTA- ENG/DESIGN - ADMIN/MAINT FACILITY

$800,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$800,000

RTDTBD13

MVR - 5339 Bus & Bus Facil- ity Discretionary: Improve- ments to the McGovern Transportation Center

$1,200,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,200,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 38

2024 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010753

MVRTA Replace 8 model yr

2012 35’ buses delivery 2024

(8 of 8)

$4,703,200

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$4,703,200

RTD0010754

MVRTA Preventative Mainte- nance for Service

$3,618,265

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$3,618,265

RTD0010755

MVRTA Operating Assis- tance for Service

$1,429,680

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,429,680

RTD0010756

MVRTA ADA Paratransit

Service

$1,963,500

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,963,500

RTD0010757

MVMPO Short Range Transit

Planning

$100,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$100,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 39

2024 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010759

MVRTA Replace 1 Model Year 2018 Supervisory Vehi- cle

$51,845

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$51,845

RTD0011302

MVRTA- METROPOLITAN PLANNING

$65,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$65,000

RTD0011308

MVRTA- ENG/DESIGN - ADMIN/MAINT FACILITY

$1,250,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,250,000

RTD0011309

MVRTA- CONSTRUCT ADMIN/MAINT FACILITY

$10,950,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$10,950,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 40

2024 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/

FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTDTBD14

MVRTA- 5339 Bus & Bus Facility Discretionary: Ex- pansion of MVRTA Bus Maintenance Facility & Possible New Bus Hub at Bradford CR Station

$4,800,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$4,800,000

RTDFERRY01

MVRTA- 5307(h) Passen- ger Ferry Grant Discretion- ary Program: Capital costs for launch of Merrimack River ferryboat service be- tween Haverhill and New- buryport

$750,000

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in

Emissions.

$750,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 41

2025 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010760

MVMPO Short Range Transit

Planning

$100,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$100,000

RTD0010761

MVRTA Preventative Mainte- nance for Service

$3,690,630

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$3,690,630

RTD0010762

MVRTA Operating Assis- tance for Service

$1,458,270

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,458,270

RTD0010763

MVRTA ADA Paratransit

Service

$2,071,500

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$2,071,500

RTD0010764

MVRTA Replace 1 Model Year 2019 Supervisory Vehi- cle

$53,400

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$53,400



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 42

2025 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0011303

MVRTA- METROPOLITAN PLANNING

$65,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$65,000

RTD0011317

MVRTA- CONSTRUCT - MISC EQUIPMENT

$625,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$625,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 43

2026 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0010765

MVRTA- Preventative

Maintenance for service

$3,810,350

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$3,810,350

RTD0010766

MVRTA- ADA Paratransit

Service

$2,185,500

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$2,185,500

RTD0010767

Merrimack Valley MPO Short

Range Transit Planning

$100,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$100,000

RTD0010768

MVRTA- Operating Assis- tance for Service

$1,502,020

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,502,020

RTD0010769

MVRTA- Replace 1 Model Yr

2020 Supervisory Vehicle

$55,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$55,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 44

2026 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0011318

MVRTA- CONSTRUCT - MISC EQUIPMENT

$125,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$125,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 45

2027 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Programmed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0011311

MVRTA- OPERATING ASSISTANCE

$1,585,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$1,585,000

RTD0011312

MVRTA- PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE

$2,500,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$2,500,000

RTD0011313

MVRTA- PLANNING

$120,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$120,000

RTD0011314

MVRTA- NON FIXED ROUTE ADA PARA SERV

$2,305,700

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$2,305,700

RTD0011315

MVRTA- BUY REPLACEMENT 35-FT BUS

$10,000,000

Qualitative

Qualitative Decrease in Emissions.

$10,000,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 46

2027 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.)

MassDOT/ FTA Project ID

MassDOT/ FTA Project Description

Total Programmed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Total Cost

Total Cost

RTD0011316

MVRTA- CONSTRUCT - MISC EQUIPMENT

$5,000,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$5,000,000

RTD0011319

MVRTA- CONSTRUCT - MISC EQUIPMENT

$125,000

Qualitative

No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions

$125,000



Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 47

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2027

MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Amesbury

Project: Riverwalk Connector to the Salisbury Point Ghost Trail # 611977

Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):




If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :

A. Facility Length (L):

0.2

Miles

B. Service Area Radius (R):

1.0

Miles

(Default = 1

C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA

0.44

Sq. Miles

D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T):

12.3

Sq. Miles

E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA):

SA / T = LA

3.6%

F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP):

17,366

Persons

G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P

621

Persons

H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH):

7,215

HH

I.

Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS

258

HH

J.

Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W):

9,688

Persons

K.

Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH

1.34

Persons


L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 347 Persons

M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 1,412 Persons Per Sq. Mile

N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 1.4% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.

http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html

O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 5 One-Way Trips

P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 8 One-Way Trips

(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)

Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction Per Day:

A. ((2 * BWT) + (2 * BNWT)) * (0.5* L) = VMTR 2.9 VMTR Per Day

B. VMTR * Operating Days Per Year 2.9 * 200 = 576 VMTR Per Year If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.



Step 3: Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:

Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern or Western Eastern

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

Summer VOC Factor

Summer NOx Factor

Summer CO Factor

Summer CO2 Factor

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

0.030

0.081

2.095

338.769

Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):





Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

Project Emission Reduction First year cost

Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram

Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO

Summer CO2

/ 0.0 = $119,826,223

/ 0.0 = $44,380,083

/ 1.2 = $1,715,889

/ 195.3 = $10,811

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 48

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR:

2025

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Georgetown, Boxford

Project: # 607541 Georgetown-Boxford Border to Boston Trail

Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):




If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :

A. Facility Length (L):

2.0

Miles

B. Service Area Radius (R):

1.0

Miles

(Default = 1 Mile)

C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA

4

Sq. Miles

D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T):

36.5

Sq. Miles

E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA):

SA / T = LA

11.0%

F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP):

16,579

Persons

G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P

1,817

Persons

H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH):

5,828

HH

I.

Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS

639

HH

J.

Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W):

8,647

Persons

K.

Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH

1.48

Persons


L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 948 Persons

M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 454 Persons Per Sq. Mile

N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 0.8% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.

http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html

O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 7 One-Way Trips

P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 12 One-Way Trips

(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)

Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction Per Day:

A. ((2 * BWT) + (2 * BNWT)) * (0.5* L) = VMTR 39.4 VMTR Per Day

B. VMTR * Operating Days Per Year 39.4 * 200 = 7,872 VMTR Per Year If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.



Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:

Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern or Western Eastern

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

Summer VOC Factor

Summer NOx Factor

Summer CO Factor

Summer CO2 Factor

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

0.030

0.081

2.095

338.769

Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):





Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

Project Emission Reduction First year cost

Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram

Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO

Summer CO2

/ 0.2 = $10,139,736

/ 0.7 = $3,712,090

/ 16.8 = $144,253

/ 2,666.9 = $909

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 49

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2025

MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Georgetown/Newbury

Project: # 607542 Georgetown-Newbury Border to Boston Trail

Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):




If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :

A. Facility Length (L):

3.6

Miles

B. Service Area Radius (R):

1.0

Miles

(Default = 1 Mile)

C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA

7.2

Sq. Miles

D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T):

36.3

Sq. Miles

E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA):

SA / T = LA

19.8%

F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP):

15,088

Persons

G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P

2,993

Persons

H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH):

5,808

HH

I.

Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS

1,152

HH

J.

Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W):

8,055

Persons

K.

Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH

1.39

Persons


L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 1,598 Persons

M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 416 Persons Per Sq. Mile

N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 1.5% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.

http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html

O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 24 One-Way Trips

P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 40 One-Way Trips

(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)

Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction Per Day:

A. ((2 * BWT) + (2 * BNWT)) * (0.5* L) = VMTR 231.5 VMTR Per Day

B. VMTR * Operating Days Per Year 231.5 * 200 = 46,290 VMTR Per Year If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.



Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:

Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern or Western Eastern

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

Summer VOC Factor

Summer NOx Factor

Summer CO Factor

Summer CO2 Factor

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

0.030

0.081

2.095

338.769

Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):





Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

Project Emission Reduction First year cost

Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram

Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO

Summer CO2

/ 1.4 = $3,611,802

/ 3.8 = $1,322,257

/ 98.8 = $51,383

/ 15,681.6 = $363

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 50

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Traffic Flow and Intersection Improvements

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2027

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Haverhill

Project:

North Avenue Reconstruction

Step 1: Calculate Existing AM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 19 + SB = 48 + EB = 114 + WB = 45,632 +

= 5,240 +

= 5,781 +

= 85 +

= 0 +

= 1,542 = 6,801

= 19 = 5,849

= 341 = 540

= 9,663 = 55,295

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 68,485

Step 2: Calculate Existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 19 + SB = 95 + EB = 60 + WB = 201,895 +

= 15,059 +

= 16,022 +

= 30 +

= 0 +

= 4,571 = 19,649

= 95 = 16,213

= 510 = 600

= 33,895 = 235,789

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 272,251

Step 3: The spreadsheet automatically chooses the peak hour with the longer total intersection delay for the next step in the analysis.

Peak Hour (AM/PM): PM

Total Intersection Delay:

272,251

Step 4: Calculate the existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay with Improvements:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB SB EB WB

Step 5: Calculate vehicle delay in hours per day:

= 19 +

= 95 +

= 60 +

= 138,731 +

= 15,059 +

= 16,022 +

= 30 +

= 0 +

= 4,571 = 19,649

= 95 = 16,213

= 508 = 598

= 23,291 = 162,021

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 198,481

Existing peak hour intersection delay

Peak hour intersection delay w/ improvements

( Delay in seconds

( 272,251

( 198,481

X Hours per day) / X 10 ) / X 10 ) /

Seconds per hour

3600

3600

= Delay in hours / day

= 756.3

= 551.3

Step 6: MOBILE 6 emission factors for idling speed: AM or PM PM

2020 2020 2020 2020

Summer VOC Factor Summer NOx Factor Winter CO Factor Summer CO2 Factor grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour

0.249 0.630 3.569 3565.610

Step 7: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per day:

Delay in Summer VOC Emissions Summer NOx Emissions Winter CO Emissions Summer CO2 Emissions

Hours per Day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day

Existing Conditions 756.3

With Improvements 551.3

Net Change

0.188

0.137

-0.051

0.476

0.347

-0.129

2.699

1.968

-0.731

2,696.505

1,965.847

-730.658

Step 8: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per year (seasonally adjusted)

Net change Avg. weekdays

Seasonal adj.

Adj. net change

per day (kg) X

per year

X factor =

in kg per year

Summer VOC Emissions -0.051 X 250 X 1.0188 = Summer NOx Emissions -0.129 X 250 X 1.0188 = Winter CO Emissions -0.731 X 250 X 0.9812 = Summer CO2 Emissions -730.658 X 250 X 1.0000

Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

-12.996

-32.881

-179.401

-182,664.532

Project

Adj. net change

First year cost


Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 51

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Traffic Flow and Intersection Improvements

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2027

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Haverhill

Project:

North Avenue Reconstruction North Ave Marsh and Tenadel Aves.

Step 1: Calculate Existing AM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 18 + SB = 1,110 + EB = 94 + WB = 477 +

= 2,379 +

= 3,608 +

= 0 +

= 0 +

= 177 = 2,573

= 0 = 4,718

= 125 = 220

= 2,317 = 2,794

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 10,305

Step 2: Calculate Existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

Marsh Ave

North Ave

Tenadel Ave

North Ave

Step 3: The spreadsheet automatically chooses the peak hour with the longer total intersection delay for the next step in the analysis.

Peak Hour (AM/PM): PM

Total Intersection Delay:

23,087

Step 4: Calculate the existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay with Improvements:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB SB EB WB

Step 5: Calculate vehicle delay in hours per day:

= 23 +

= 1,266 +

= 4 +

= 251 +

= 6,472 +

= 2,460 +

= 0 +

= 9 +

= 250 = 6,745

= 0 = 3,727

= 8 = 13

= 3,740 = 3,999

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 14,484

Existing peak hour intersection delay

Peak hour intersection delay w/ improvements

( Delay in seconds

( 23,087

( 14,484

X Hours per day) / X 10 ) / X 10 ) /

Seconds per hour

3600

3600

= Delay in hours / day

= 64.1

= 40.2

Step 6: MOBILE 6 emission factors for idling speed: AM or PM PM

2020 2020 2020 2020

Summer VOC Factor Summer NOx Factor Winter CO Factor Summer CO2 Factor grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour

0.249 0.630 3.569 3565.610

Step 7: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per day:

Delay in Summer VOC Emissions Summer NOx Emissions Winter CO Emissions Summer CO2 Emissions

Hours per Day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day

Existing Conditions 64.1

With Improvements 40.2

Net Change

0.016

0.010

-0.006

0.040

0.025

-0.015

0.229

0.144

-0.085

228.665

143.457

-85.208

Step 8: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per year (seasonally adjusted)

Net change Avg. weekdays

Seasonal adj.

Adj. net change

per day (kg) X

per year

X factor =

in kg per year

Summer VOC Emissions -0.006 X 250 X 1.0188 = Summer NOx Emissions -0.015 X 250 X 1.0188 = Winter CO Emissions -0.085 X 250 X 0.9812 = Summer CO2 Emissions -85.208 X 250 X 1.0000

Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

-1.516

-3.835

-20.921

-21,301.913

Project

Adj. net change

First year cost


Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 52

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Traffic Flow and Intersection Improvements

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2027

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Haverhill

Project:

North Avenue Reconstruction North Ave, Gile St and West Gile St

Step 1: Calculate Existing AM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 0 + SB = 245 + EB = 0 + WB = 2,931 +

= 3,286 +

= 5,836 +

= 0 +

= 0 +

= 546 = 3,832

= 9 = 6,090

= 44 = 44

= 1,127 = 4,059

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 14,023

Step 2: Calculate Existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 0 + SB = 409 + EB = 0 + WB = 11,217 +

= 8,053 +

= 5,343 +

= 0 +

= 0 +

= 1,011 = 9,064

= 0 = 5,752

= 0 = 0

= 7,276 = 18,493

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 33,309

Step 3: The spreadsheet automatically chooses the peak hour with the longer total intersection delay for the next step in the analysis.

Peak Hour (AM/PM): PM

Total Intersection Delay:

33,309

Step 4: Calculate the existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay with Improvements:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB SB EB WB

Step 5: Calculate vehicle delay in hours per day:

= 0 +

= 409 +

= 0 +

= 13,320 +

= 8,053 +

= 5,343 +

= 0 +

= 0 +

= 1,011 = 9,064

= 0 = 5,752

= 0 = 0

= 970 = 14,290

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 29,106

Existing peak hour intersection delay

Peak hour intersection delay w/ improvements

( Delay in seconds

( 33,309

( 29,106

X Hours per day) / X 10 ) / X 10 ) /

Seconds per hour

3600

3600

= Delay in hours / day

= 92.5

= 80.9

Step 6: MOBILE 6 emission factors for idling speed: AM or PM PM

2020 2020 2020 2020

Summer VOC Factor Summer NOx Factor Winter CO Factor Summer CO2 Factor grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour

0.249 0.630 3.569 3565.610

Step 7: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per day:

Delay in Summer VOC Emissions Summer NOx Emissions Winter CO Emissions Summer CO2 Emissions

Hours per Day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day

Existing Conditions 92.5

With Improvements 80.9

Net Change

0.023

0.020

-0.003

0.058

0.051

-0.007

0.330

0.289

-0.042

329.905

288.282

-41.624

Step 8: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per year (seasonally adjusted)

Net change Avg. weekdays

Seasonal adj.

Adj. net change

per day (kg) X

per year

X factor =

in kg per year

Summer VOC Emissions -0.003 X 250 X 1.0188 = Summer NOx Emissions -0.007 X 250 X 1.0188 = Winter CO Emissions -0.042 X 250 X 0.9812 = Summer CO2 Emissions -41.624 X 250 X 1.0000

Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

-0.740

-1.873

-10.220

-10,405.951

Project

Adj. net change

First year cost


Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 53

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR:

2023

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Lawrence

Project: Lawrence Manchester Rail Corriodr (LMRC) Rail Trail Project # 608930

Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):




If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :

A. Facility Length (L):

1.5

Miles

B. Service Area Radius (R):

1.0

Miles

(Default = 1 Mile)

C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA

2.92

Sq. Miles

D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T):

6.93

Sq. Miles

E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA):

SA / T = LA

42.1%

F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP):

79,337

Persons

G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P

33,429

Persons

H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH):

25,759

HH

I.

Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS

10,854

HH

J.

Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W):

33,261

Persons

K.

Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH

1.29

Persons


L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 14,015 Persons

M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 11,448 Persons Per Sq. Mile

N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 4.7% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.

http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html

O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 659 One-Way Trips

P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 1,120 One-Way Trips

(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)

Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction Per Day:

A. ((2 * BWT) + (2 * BNWT)) * (0.5* L) = VMTR 2596.6 VMTR Per Day

B. VMTR * Operating Days Per Year 2,596.6 * 200 = 519,313 VMTR Per Year If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.



Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:

Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern or Western Eastern

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

Summer VOC Factor

Summer NOx Factor

Summer CO Factor

Summer CO2 Factor

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

0.030

0.081

2.095

338.769

Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):





Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

Project Emission Reduction First year cost

Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram

Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO

Summer CO2

/ 15.8 = $1,306,100

/ 43.1 = $478,155

/ 1,108.2 = $18,581

/ 175,927.3 = $117

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 54

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Traffic Flow and Intersection Improvements

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2023

MPO:

Merrimack Valley

Municipality:

Methuen

Project:

# 610658 Intersection Improvements at Methuen Riverside Dr and Burnham Rd

Step 1: Calculate Existing AM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 35 + SB = 2,293 + EB = 111 + WB = 1 +

= 35 +

= 382 +

= 553 +

= 61 +

= 159 = 230

= 2,407 = 5,082

= 4 = 668

= 17 = 79

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 6,058

Step 2: Calculate Existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 25 + SB = 100,445 + EB = 244 + WB = 8 +

= 246 +

= 6,623 +

= 962 +

= 208 +

= 296 = 567

= 41,944 = 149,012

= 12 = 1,218

= 67 = 283

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 151,079

Step 3: The spreadsheet automatically chooses the peak hour with the longer total intersection delay for the next step in the analysis.

Peak Hour (AM/PM): PM

Total Intersection Delay:

151,079

Step 4: Calculate the existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay with Improvements:

Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total

Street Name Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh

= move. delay

= approach delay

NB = 9 + SB = 2,452 + EB = 985 + WB = 224 +

= 95 +

= 162 +

= 3,879 +

= 5,530 +

= 114 = 218

= 1,024 = 3,638

= 49 = 4,914

= 1,778 = 7,532

Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 16,302

Step 5: Calculate vehicle delay in hours per day:

(

Delay in seconds

X Hours per day) /

Seconds per hour

= Delay in hours / day

Existing peak hour intersection delay (

Peak hour intersection delay w/ improvements (

151,079

16,302

X 10 ) /

X 10 ) /

3600

3600

= 419.7

= 45.3

Step 6: MOBILE 6 emission factors for idling speed: AM or PM PM

2020 2020 2020 2020

Summer VOC Factor Summer NOx Factor Winter CO Factor Summer CO2 Factor grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour grams/hour

0.249 0.630 3.569 3565.610

Step 7: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per day:

Delay in Summer VOC Emissions Summer NOx Emissions Winter CO Emissions Summer CO2 Emissions

Hours per Day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day kilograms/day

Existing Conditions 419.7

With Improvements 45.3

Net Change

0.104

0.011

-0.093

0.264

0.029

-0.236

1.498

0.162

-1.336

1,496.360

161.461

-1,334.900

Step 8: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per year (seasonally adjusted)

Net change Avg. weekdays

Seasonal adj.

Adj. net change

per day (kg) X

per year

X factor =

in kg per year

Summer VOC Emissions -0.093 X 250 X 1.0188 = Summer NOx Emissions -0.236 X 250 X 1.0188 = Winter CO Emissions -1.336 X 250 X 0.9812 = Summer CO2 Emissions -1,334.900 X 250 X 1.0000

Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

-23.743

-60.074

-327.762

-333,724.936

Emission

Project

Cost /

Adj. net change

in kg per year =

First year cost

per kilogram

Summer VOC / Summer NOx / Winter CO /

Summer CO2 /

-23.743 =

-60.074 =

-327.762 =

-333,724.936 =

$39,169

$15,481

$2,837

$3


Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 55

CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project

FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY

TIP YEAR: 2023

MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Salisbury

Project: # 602202 Reconstruction of Route 1 (Lafayette Road) Shared Use Path

Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):




If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :

A. Facility Length (L):

2.1

Miles

B. Service Area Radius (R):

1.0

Miles

(Default = 1 Mile)

C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA

4.2

Sq. Miles

D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T):

15.4

Sq. Miles

E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA):

SA / T = LA

27.3%

F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP):

9,379

Persons

G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P

2,558

Persons

H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH):

3,889

HH

I.

Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS

1,061

HH

J.

Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W):

6,059

Persons

K.

Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH

1.56

Persons


L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 1,652 Persons

M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 609 Persons Per Sq. Mile

N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 4.4% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.

http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html

O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 73 One-Way Trips

P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 124 One-Way Trips

(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)

Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction Per Day:

A. ((2 * BWT) + (2 * BNWT)) * (0.5* L) = VMTR 412.3 VMTR Per Day

B. VMTR * Operating Days Per Year 412.3 * 200 = 82,451 VMTR Per Year If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.



Step 3: Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:

Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern or Western Eastern

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

2020 Passenger

Summer VOC Factor

Summer NOx Factor

Summer CO Factor

Summer CO2 Factor

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

grams/mile

0.030

0.081

2.095

338.769

Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):





Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)

Project Emission Reduction First year cost

Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram

Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO

Summer CO2

/ 2.5 = $378,567

/ 6.8 = $140,210

/ 176.0 = $5,421

/ 27,931.8 = $34

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 56

Appendix F Completed Highway and Transit Projects GHG Summary

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 57

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

606503

NEWBURYPORT CLIPPER CITY RAIL TRAIL ALONG THE CITY BRANCH (PHASE II)

$4,061,158

Quantitative

34,996

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure

Advertised

9/19/2015

Notice to Pro- ceed

4/1/2016

2016

606161

HAVERHILL- IMPROVEMENTS ON MAIN STREET (ROUTE

125)

$3,635,519

Quantitative

16,491

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improve- ment

Advertised

9/17/2016

Notice to Pro- ceed

4/12/2017

2017

607573

HAVERHILL- RECONSTRUCTION ON ROUTE 97 (BROADWAY), FROM SILVER BIRCH LANE TO RESEARCH DRIVE

$6,526,912

Quantitative

41,800

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improve- ment

Advertised

5/13/2017

Notice to Pro- ceed

2/9/2018

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 58

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Im- pact (kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

604585

FLEX TO FTA FOR MVRTA NEW BUS UPGRADE TO CLEANER FUEL BUSES

$645,840

Quantitative

26,343

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

Flexed to

FTA

2017

605020

SALISBURY- MULTI- USE TRAIL EXTENSION (BORDERS TO BOSTON TRAIL), INCLUDES NEW BRIDGE S-02-004 AND BOARDWALK (S-02-

012) (BYX)

$5,918,500

Quantitative

18,631

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure

Advertised

8/25/2018

Contract

Awarded

12/12/18

Notice to Pro- ceed 1/18/19

2018

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 59

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

602418

AMESBURY- RECONSTRUCTION OF ELM STREET

$11,178,124

Quantitative

1,336

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Complete Streets Project

Advertised

7/13/2019. Notice to Pro- ceed

12/13/19.

AC 2019 and

2020

607737

AMESBURY- SALISBURY- TRAIL CONNECTOR @ I-95

$2,574,805

Quantitative

3,972

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure

Advertised

9/15/2018

Notice to Pro- ceed 4/18/19

2019

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 60

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

606159

NORTH ANDOVER- INTERSECTION & SIGNAL IMPROVEMENTS AT ROUTE 125 & MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE

$5,446,662

Quantitative

482,727

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement

Advertised

1/12/2019

Notice to Pro- ceed 8/14/19

2019

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 61

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

608027

HAVERHILL- BRADFORD RAIL TRAIL EXTENSION, FROM ROUTE 125 TO RAILROAD STREET

$1,766,108

Quantitative

422

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure

Notice to Pro- ceed

10/23/2020

2020

609251

LAWRENCE – INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS AT SOUTH BROADWAY (ROUTE 28) AND MOUNT VERNON STREET

$1,218,368

Quantitative

380,222

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement

Advertised

1/16/2021

2021

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 62

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

Mass DOT/ Project ID

MassDOT Project

Description

Total Pro- grammed Funds

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional

Description

Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward)

608298

Groveland – Community Trail from Main Street to King Street

$2,954,832

Quantitative

2,710

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure

Notice to Pro- ceed

9/27/2021

2021

608761

Haverhill – Intersection

Reconstruction on Rt.

108 (Newton Road) at Rt. 110 (Kenoza Ave. and Amesbury Rd.)

$3,376,283

Quantitative

8,307

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement

Advertised

8/21/21. Notice to Pro- ceed

10/22/21.

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 63

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Transit Projects GHG Tracking Summary

FTA Activity Line Item

Transit

Agency

Project

Description

Total

Cost

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional Descrip- tion

Fiscal Year Pro- grammed (2015 and forward)

MVRTA

Purchase Re- placement Vans

11 Model Year

2009 Delivery

2015

$627,000

Quantitative

41,814

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

2015

111202

MVRTA

Replace 10 of 17

Model Year 2004

Transit Buses with new buses (Deliv- ery 2016)

$4,200,000

Quantitative

12,557

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

2015

111215

MVRTA

Replace 5 Model Year 2011 Para- transit Vehicles (Delivery 2016)

$320,000

Quantitative

15,992

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

2016

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 64

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Transit Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

FTA Activity Line Item

Transit

Agency

Project

Description

Total

Cost

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional Descrip- tion

Fiscal Year Pro- grammed (2015 and forward)

111202

MVRTA

Replace 7 MY

2004 Transit Buses with new buses

$2,989,000

Quantitative

18,271

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

2017

111202

MVRTA

Replace 6 Model Year 2004 Buses (Delivery 2018)

$2,689,500

Quantitative

15,661

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement

2018

RTD00

07687

MVRTA

Replace 3 Model Yr 2007 buses de- livery 2020

$1,377,150

Quantitative

8,166

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus

Replacement

2020

RTD00

08596

MVRTA

Replace 16 Model Yr 2015 vans with new delivery 2021

$1,180,480

Quantitative

33,208

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus

Replacement

2021

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 65

Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Transit Projects GHG Tracking Summary

(Cont.)

FTA Activity Line Item

Transit

Agency

Project

Description

Total

Cost

GHG Analysis Type

GHG CO2

Impact

(kg/yr)

GHG Impact

Description

Additional Descrip- tion

Fiscal Year Pro- grammed (2015 and forward)

RTD00

09673

MVRTA

MVRTA Replace 9

Model Yr 2009 35’

buses delivery

2022

$4,458,030

Quantitative

25,777

Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacements

2022

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 66

Appendix G List of Acronyms

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 67

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms

A

AADT

Average Annual Daily Traffic

AASHTO

American Association of State Highway Transpor- tation Officials

ABP

MassDOT Accelerated Bridge Program

AC

Advance Construction

ADA

Americans with Disabilities Act (1990)

ADT

Average Daily Traffic

AQ

Air Quality

B

B to B

Border to Boston Rail Trail

BFP

Bridge Formula Program

BIL

Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill (BIL) signed into law as the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act No- vember 15, 2021 Public Law 117-58

C

3C

Continuing, Comprehensive and Coordinated

(Transportation Planning)

CAAA

Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990

CFR

Code of Federal Regulations

CIP

Capital Investment Plan

CLF

Conservation Law Foundation

CMAQ

Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improve- ment Program

CMP

Congestion Management Process

CMR

Code of Massachusetts Regulations

CNG

Compressed Natural Gas

CO

Carbon Monoxide

CO2

Carbon Dioxide

CRP

Carbon Reduction Program

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 68

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms (Cont.)

C

(Cont.)

CRRSAA

Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental

Appropriations Act

D

DEP

Department of Environmental Protection

DOT

Department of Transportation

DPW

Department of Public Works

E

EB

Eastbound

EIR

Environmental Impact Report

EIS

Environmental Impact Statement

EJ

Environmental Justice

ENF

Environmental Notification Form

E.O.

Executive Order (of the Governor of the Common- wealth)

EPA

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

F

FA

Federal-Aid

FAPRO

Federal Aid Program Reimbursement Office

FAST Act

Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act legis- lation signed into law December 4, 2015

FHWA

Federal Highway Administration

FTA

Federal Transit Administration

FY

(State) Fiscal Year

FFY

Federal Fiscal Year

G

GANs

Grant Anticipation Notes

GHG

Greenhouse Gas

H

HPP

USDOT High Priority Project

HSIP

Highway Safety Improvement Program

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 69

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms (Cont.)

I

IIJA

Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act signed into law November 15, 2021 Public Law 117-58 also known as the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill (BIL)

I

IM

Interstate Maintenance

ITS

Intelligent Transportation System

ISTEA

Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act of

1991

L

LEP

Limited English Proficiency

LOS

Level of Service

LTA

Local Technical Assistance

M

MAP

Mobility Assistance Program

MAP-21

Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century legis- lation signed into law July 6, 2012

MassDOT

Massachusetts Department of Transportation

MCAD

Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination

MEPA

Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act

M.G.L.

Massachusetts General Laws

MOA

Memorandum of Agreement

MOD

Massachusetts Office on Disabilities

MOU

Memorandum of Understanding

MPO

Metropolitan Planning Organization

MVMPO

Merrimack Valley Metropolitan Planning Organiza- tion

MVPC

Merrimack Valley Planning Commission

MVPGS

Merrimack Valley Priority Growth Strategy

MVRTA

Merrimack Valley Regional Transit Authority

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 70

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms (Cont.)

N

NAAQS

National Ambient Air Quality Standards

NARC

National Association of Regional Councils

NB

Northbound

NEPA

National Environmental Policy Act

NFA

Non-Federal Aid

NGBP

Next Generation Bridge Program

NHS

National Highway System

NMCOG

Northern Middlesex Council of Governments

NOx

Nitrogen Oxide

NPRM

Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (Federal Register)

O&M

Operations and Maintenance

OTP

MassDOT Office of Transportation Planning

P

PCI

Pavement Condition Index

PDA

Priority Development Area

PL

(Metropolitan) Planning Funds

PMS

Pavement Management System

PPP

Public Participation Plan

PRC

(MassDOT) Project Review Committee

PSAC

Project Selection Advisory Council

PS&E

The Plans, Specifications and Estimate to be used by contractors to bid on construction proposals

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 71

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms (Cont.)

R

RGGI

Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative

ROW

Right-of-Way

RPA

Regional Planning Agency

RPMS

Regional Pavement Management System

RTA

Regional Transit Authority

RTP

Regional Transportation Plan

S

SAFETEA-LU

Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transporta- tion Equity Act: A Legacy for Users

SB

Southbound

SD

Structurally Deficient

SGR

State of Good Repair

SIP

State (Air Quality) Implementation Plan

SOV

Single Occupancy Vehicle

SPR

Statewide Planning and Research Funds

STBG

Surface Transportation Block Grant Program

STIP

Statewide Transportation Improvement Program

STP

Surface Transportation Program

T

TA

Transportation Alternatives

TAM

Transit Asset Management

TAP

Transportation Alternatives Program

TCSP

Transportation and Community System Preserva- tion Grant Program

TDM

Transportation Demand Management

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 72

MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms (Cont.)

T (Con.)

TEA-21

Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century

TEC

Transportation Project Evaluation Criteria

TERM score

Transit Economic Requirements Model score used to rate transit facility conditions

TIP

Transportation Improvement Program

TMA

Transportation Management Area

TMC

Turning Movement Count

TOD

Transit-Oriented Development

TRB

Transportation Research Board

U

ULB

Useful Life Benchmark

UPWP

Unified Planning Work Program

USDOT

U.S. Department of Transportation

V

V/C

Volume/Capacity Ratio

VMT

Vehicle Miles Traveled

VOC

Volatile Organic Compound

W

WB

Westbound

Massachusetts Executive Orders

EO

526

Nondiscrimination, Diversity, Equal Employment

Opportunity and Affirmative Action

EO

12898

Environmental Justice in Minority and Low-Income

Populations, February 1994

EO

13166

Improving Access to Programs (and Services) for

persons with limited English Proficiency

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 73

Appendix H Key to Maps Showing Locations of Transportation Projects

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 74

Appendix H Key to Maps Showing Locations of Transportation Projects

Map

Number

Project Num- ber

City/Town

Project Description

1

611977

Amesbury

Amesbury– Riverwalk Connector to the

Salisbury Point Ghost Trail

2

612193

Andover

Andover- Bridge Preservation, A-09-022, I-

93 over Merrimack River

3

606522

Andover

Andover- Bridge Rehabilitation, A-09-036,

I-495 over St 28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495 over

B&M and MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 over St

28 (NB)

4

612143

Andover

Andover– Bridge Replacement, A-09-015, Tewksbury Street over MBTA/BMRR

5

612045

Andover- Tewksbury

Andover-Tewksbury- Interstate

Maintenance and related work on I-93

6

607541

Georgetown- Boxford

Georgetown– Boxford Border to Boston Trail from Georgetown Road to West Main Street (Route 97)

6

607542

Georgetown- Newbury

Georgetown– Newbury Border to Boston Trail (Northern Georgetown to Byfield Section)

7

S12208

Groveland

Groveland- Improvements at Dr. Elmer

Bagnall Elementary School

8

605304

Haverhill

Haverhill- Bridge Replacement, H-12-007 & H-12-025, Bridge Street (SR 125) over Merrimack River and the Abandoned B&M RR (Proposed Bikeway)

9

609466

Haverhill

Haverhill– Bridge Replacement, H-12-040, I-495 (NB & SB) over Merrimack River

10

608788

Haverhill

Haverhill– Roadway Reconstruction on

North Avenue, from Main Street (Route

125) to Plaistow, NH

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 75

Appendix H Key to Maps Showing Locations of Transportation Projects

(Continued)

Map

Number

Project

Number

City/Town

Project Description

11

612074

Lawrence

Lawrence– Bridge Replacement, L-04-012, Short Street over Spicket River

12

612002

Lawrence

Lawrence– Community Day Arlington

Improvements (SRTS)

11

608930

Lawrence

Lawrence- Lawrence Manchester Rail

Corridor (LMRC) Rail Trail

11

610924

Lawrence

Lawrence– Roadway Reconstruction on

Amesbury Street

13

612158

Methuen

Methuen- Bridge Replacement, M-17-026, Route 213 EB/WB over the Methuen Rail Trail

2

610658

Methuen

Methuen– Intersection Improvements at

Riverside Drive and Burnham Road

8

MVRTA-1

MVRTA

MVRTA- New facility and/or division gargage in Bradford

11

MVRTA- 2

MVRTA

MVRTA- McGovern Transportation Center upgrades

14

608029

Newburyport

Newburyport– Intersection Improvements

@ Route 1 & Merrimac Street

3

608095

North

Andover

North Andover- Corridor Improvements on Route 114, between Waverly Road & Willow/Mill Street

15

609392

Rowley

Rowley– Safety Improvements at Route 1, Central and Glen Streets

1

602202

Salisbury

Salisbury– Reconstruction of Route 1 (Lafayette Road)

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 76

Appendix I Comments Received on Draft TIP

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 77

MPO Liaison TIP Review Checklist

Completeness

ID

Review Item

Comments

Responses

Reference

A1

*

Table of Contents is accurate and internally-linked.

✔ ‐‐ for use in column B

A2

*

Document has no broken links.

❌ ‐‐ for use in column B

A3

*

MPO self certification statement is included.

Please reformat the numbering of the items listed in the Self-Certification.

Change made.

A4

*

GHG certification is included.

A5

*

Air Quality Conformity statement is included.

A6

*

Document has no text or image placeholders.

A7

*

Charts, tables, and maps are legible and properly annotated.

A8

*

Document passes an accessible check.

A9

*

Document is available in relevant languages per the MPO's

Title VI Plan.

A10

*

List of MPO members is current.

A11

*

Signatory sheet is included and accurate.

Please fix the signatory field for Global Warming

Solutions Act – Signatures (page 9).

Change made.

A12

*

Acronyms and partner agency lists are up to date.

A13

*

Dates listed w/in TIP reflect FFY 2023–2027.

Narrative

ID

Review Item

Comments

Reference

B1

*

TIP outlines MPO institutional organization.

B2

*

TIP links back to national planning factors.

B3

*

TIP references the RTP and the UPWP.

B4

*

TIP narrative is concise and reader-friendly.

This document needs to go on a diet. 258 pages is not concise--please consider hyperlinks to external sources or appendices as applicable.

Will hyperlink Appendix.

B5

*

TIP discusses evaluation scoring.

B6

*

TIP includes project scoring table.

B7

*

TIP describes public participation process.

B8

*

TIP includes procedures for adjustments and amendments, including any deviations from MassDOT guidelines.

B9

*

TIP describes funding sources accurately.

Pages 114 - 118, reformatting these to landscape

could fit into fewer pages and be more redaer- friendly. Please consider revsion.

Change made.

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/specialfunding/

Performance Measurement

ID

Review Item

Comments

Reference

C1

*

TIP includes discussion of target-setting process.

C2

*

TIP references relevant Transit Asset Management (TAM) Plans and includes all TAM Plan targets.

https://www.transit.dot.gov/TAM/TAMPlans

C3

*

TIP references relevant Public Transportation Agency Safety

Plans (PTASPs) and includes all PTASP targets

https://www.transit.dot.gov/PTASP

C4

*

TIP includes current adopted performance targets.

PM1, PM2, PM3, TAM, and any regionally-derived targets

C5

*

TIP discusses relationship between performance targets and project selection.

C6

Discussion on performance measures compares regional data to statewide data where available.

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 78

MPO Liaison TIP Review Checklist

Project Listing

ID

Review Item

Comments

Reference

D1

*

Financial projections align with MassDOT guidance.

Please verify that all cost and TIP financials are up to date.

The recent updates to the highway project list from eSTIP will be included.

D2

*

TIP template is formatted correctly.

When exporting the STIP Investment Reports

please check Add’l Information check box.

The Add'l information is included.

D3

*

Projects use MassDOT ProjectInfo TFPCs.

D4

*

Out year expenditures have the appropriate inflation

assumptions.

2024: 4%; 2025: 8%; 2026: 12%; 2027: 16%

D5

*

Projects use MassDOT ProjectInfo description.

D6

*

Additional comment field contains all necessary info.

Total cost, AC, Year-of-expenditure, TEC scores

D7

*

MassDOT projects are (accurately) included into regional

template.

D8

*

Regional target projects adhere to Readiness Days feedback.

D9

*

List includes all projects, including FLAP, FLTP, and Tribal

projects.

D10

*

Transit TIP is formatted properly.

Transit project list will need revision, please reach

out to MPO liaison.

The new Transit list from eSTIP will replace the

previous list from Rail and Transit Division

Should be unchanged from GrantsPlus

Impact Analysis

ID

Review Item

Comments

Reference

E1

*

TIP includes GHG certification.

E2

*

GHG analysis is available for all (and only) funded projects.

E3

*

All projects are appropriately labeled as qualitative or

quantitative.

E4

*

Transit projects have been analyzed for GHG.

E5

*

Past and current TIP projects have been analyzed for

geographic equity, including a relevant table of programming by municipality.

E6

*

Past and current TIP projects have been analyzed for social

equity.

E7

*

Social equity analysis considers Title VI / language access.

E8

*

Social equity analysis considers EJ populations, including both

federal and state definitions.

E9

*

Equity analysis includes a narrative to accompany any figures.

* indicates required by state or federal regulation.

Final FFYs 2023-2027 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2022 Appendix 79