This document was prepared in cooperation with the Massachusetts Department of
Transportation and the U.S. Department of Transportation. (under Contracts
#95416, #MA-80-012 and #MA-80-013 with MassDOT) The views and opinions of the Merrimack Valley Planning Commission expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the Massachusetts Department of Transportation or the U.S. Department of Transportation.
Page intentionally left blank.
Appendices ....................................................................................................................... 1
Appendix A Other Regional Priority Bridge Projects ...................................................... 2
Appendix B Other Regional Priority Roadway Projects .................................................. 3
Appendix C Transportation Evaluation Criteria Summary .............................................. 7
Appendix D Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet ....................................................... 13
Appendix E Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Tracking .............................................................. 19
FFYs 2020 to 2024 Projects GHG Tracking Summary ......................... 24
Appendix F Completed Highway and Transit Projects GHG Summary .......................... 75
Appendix G List of Acronyms ......................................................................................... 81
Appendix H Key to Maps Showing Locations of Transportation Projects....................... 89
Appendix I Comments Received on Draft 2020-2024 TIP............................................. 93
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 1
Bridges That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets,
and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town):
ID | Location | Project Description | Estimated Total Project Cost |
602322 | Ames. | Amesbury - Bridge Replacement, A-07-008, Oak Street Over the B&M Railroad (Abandoned Line) | $1,000,000 |
And. | Andover - Rehab. Bridge (A-09-001) Route 28 (North Main Street) Over the Shawsheen Riv- er | ||
605418 | And. | Andover - Bridge Preservation, A-09-028, Chandler Road over I-93 | $3,450,000 |
604839 | Law. | Lawrence – Bridge Replacement, L-04-027, Lowell Street over B&M Railroad | $4,473,000 |
Law. | Lawrence - Bridge Rehabilitation, L-04-042, South Union Connector over South Street | ||
Nbypt. | Newburyport - Bridge (N-11-002) State Route 113 (High Street) Over Railroad | ||
Nbypt. | Newburyport - Bridge (N-11-014) State Route 1A (High Street) over US 1 | ||
607115 | Nbypt. | Newburyport - Bridge Repairs, N-11-015, Washington St. over US 1 | $1,400,000 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 2
Roadway Projects That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets, and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town)
ID | Location | Project Description | Estimated Total Project Cost |
608336 | Andover | Andover – Reconstruction on Route 133 (Lowell Street), from Lovejoy Road to Route 28 (North Main Street) TEC = 11.00 | $7,245,000 |
607708 | Andover | Andover - Resurfacing and related work on Route 28 TEC = 5.22 | $1,062,600 |
606721 | Boxford | Boxford - Reconstruction of Route 133 (Washington Street) from North Andover town line to Main Street TEC = 5.60 | $5,172,164 |
Boxford | Boxford Reconstruction of Route 97 from Georgetown to Topsfield (2 miles) | $3,785,000 | |
607540 | Boxford | Boxford - Border to Boston Trail TEC = 3.32 | $4,174,500 |
602843 | Georgetown | Georgetown – Reconstruction on Route 97 (W. Main Street) from Moulton Street to Groveland T.L. TEC = 6.63 | $7,239,453 |
Haverhill | Haverhill -Intersection Improvements Route 110 and Elliott Street | ||
Haverhill | Haverhill – Widen Route 97 (Broadway) from Computer Drive to Research Drive |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 3
Roadway Projects That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets,
and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town):
ID | Location | Project Description | Estimated Total Project Cost |
608721 | Haverhill | Haverhill – Corridor Improvements on Water Street (Route 97/113), from Ginty Boule- vard/Mill Street to Lincoln Boulevard/Riverside Avenue TEC = 8.18 | $8,050,000 |
602339 | Haverhill | Haverhill-Historic Waterfront Walkway Phase II (Construction) | $3,110,184 |
Lawrence/ North Andover | Lawrence - North Andover - Reconstruction of Route 114 from I-495 in Lawrence to Rt. 125 (Andover St.) in North Andover TEC = 13.05 | ||
Methuen | Methuen – Reconstruction of Route 110 from Burnham Road to Woodland Street | ||
Newbury- port | Newburyport -Route 1 Rotary Reconfiguration | ||
608029 | Newbury- port | Newburyport - Intersection Improvements Route 1 at Merrimac Street TEC = 7.67 | $2,400,000 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 4
Roadway Projects That Do Not Fit into Fiscally Constrained Targets,
and therefore have No Funding Available in Any Year (By Town):
ID | Location | Project Description | Estimated Total Project Cost |
North Andover | North Andover – Reconstruction of Mass. Ave. and Sidewalks (from Osgood St. to I-495) | ||
605694 | North Andover | North Andover - Resurfacing and related work Route 125 TEC = 7.45 | $7,910,592 |
North Andover | North Andover - Signals and turn lanes at Mass Ave. and I-495 NB and SB Ramps | ||
607710 | Salisbury | Salisbury – Resurfacing and related work Route 1A | $2,300,000 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 5
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 6
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 7
Programmed for Fund- ing in Draft TIP | ID# | Project Description | Project Cost in 1000s | AADT | Linear Lane Miles | Condition | Mobility | Safety & Security | Community Effects & Support | Land Use & Economic Development | Environmental Effects | Total TEC Score (2020- 2024) |
No | Lawrence –North Andover - Reconstruction of Rt. 114 from I-495 to Rt. 125 (Ando- ver St.) | 30,000 | 5.6 | 3.00 | 3.00 | 3.00 | 1.80 | 1.75 | 0.50 | 13.05 | ||
Yes | 608095 | North Andover – Recon- struction of Rt. 114 from Rt. 125 (Andover St.) to Stop & Shop | $16,730 | 30,000 | 4.8 | 2.00 | 2.75 | 2.67 | 1.40 | 1.75 | 0.75 | 11.32 |
Yes | 608930 | Lawrence – LMRC Rail Trail | $14,895 | NA | NA | 1.00 | 1.75 | 2.00 | 3.00 | 2.50 | 1.00 | 11.25 |
No | 608336 | Andover – Rt. 133 reconst. Lovejoy Road to Shawsheen Square (inc. Shawsheen Square) | $7,245 | 12,773 | 4.4 | 2.00 | 2.75 | 2.00 | 1.00 | 1.75 | 1.50 | 11.00 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 8
Programmed for Fund- ing in Draft TIP | ID# | Project Description | Project Cost in 1000s | AADT | Linear Lane Miles | Condition | Mobility | Safety & Security | Community Effects & Support | Land Use & Economic Development | Environmental Effects | Total TEC Score (2020- 2024) |
Yes | 608761 | Haverhill - Intersection Im- provements at Rt. 110 / Rt. 108 | $1,944 | NA | NA | 1.50 | 1.75 | 1.67 | 1.20 | 1.75 | 1.00 | 8.87 |
Yes | 602202 | Salisbury – Reconstruction of Route 1 (Lafayette Road) | $6,331 | 12,147 | 4.8 | 2.00 | 2.00 | 2.00 | 0.60 | 1.5 | 0.5 | 8.60 |
No | 608721 | Haverhill - Corridor Im- provements on Water St. from Ginty Blvd / Mill St. to Lincoln Ave./ Riverside Ave. | $8,050 | 20,200 | 2 | 1.50 | 1.75 | 1.33 | 1.60 | 1.25 | 0.75 | 8.18 |
Yes | 608788 | Haverhill - Reconstruction of North Ave. from Main St. to NH stateline | $12,213 | 13,172 | 4 | 2.50 | 1.75 | 1.00 | 2.00 | 0.00 | 0.75 | 8.00 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 9
Programmed for Fund- ing in Draft TIP | ID# | Project Description | Project Cost in 1000s | AADT | Linear Lane Miles | Condition | Mobility | Safety & Security | Community Effects & Support | Land Use & Economic Development | Environmental Effects | Total TEC Score (2020- 2024) |
No | 608029 | Newburyport – Intersection Improvements Rt. 1 at Mer- rimac St. | $2,400 | 24,850 | NA | 2.00 | 0.50 | 2.67 | 1.00 | 1.25 | 0.25 | 7.67 |
No | 605694 | North Andover – Route 125 Resurfacing and related work | $7,911 | 20,400 | 9.4 | 2.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.20 | 1.25 | 0.50 | 7.45 |
Yes | 608027 | Haverhill – Bradford Rail Trail extension | $1,088 | NA | NA | 0.50 | 1.50 | 1.00 | 2.40 | 1.25 | 0.50 | 7.15 |
No | 609251 | Lawrence – Intersection Improvements at South Broadway (Route 28) and Mount Vernon St. | $1,110 | NA | NA | 2.00 | 1.00 | 2.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 | 7.02 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 10
Programmed for Fund- ing in Draft TIP | ID# | Project Description | Project Cost in 1000s | AADT | Linear Lane Miles | Condition | Mobility | Safety & Security | Community Effects & Support | Land Use & Economic Development | Environmental Effects | Total TEC Score (2020- 2024) |
No | 602843 | Georgetown – Route 97 from Moulton St. to Groveland TL | $7,239 | 15,486 | 2.2 | 1.50 | 0.75 | 1.33 | 0.80 | 1.50 | 0.75 | 6.63 |
No | 606721 | Boxford - Route 133 (North Andover TL to Main St.) | $5,172 | 6,149 | 2.9 | 1.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.60 | 0.50 | 1.00 | 5.60 |
No | 607708 | Andover – Route 28 resurfac- ing and related work | $1,063 | 19,728 | 4.0 | 2.50 | 0.25 | 0.67 | 0.80 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 5.22 |
Yes | 607542 | Georgetown – Square to By- field (Northern) section of Bor- der to Boston Trail | $3,876 | NA | NA | 0.50 | 1.25 | 0.67 | 0.80 | 1.50 | 0.50 | 5.22 |
Yes | 607541 | Georgetown- Boxford– south of Square to Georgetown Road (Southern) section of Border to Boston Trail | $1,735 | NA | NA | 0.50 | 1.25 | 0.67 | 0.80 | 1.25 | 0.75 | 5.22 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 11
Programmed for Fund- ing in Draft TIP | ID# | Project Description | Project Cost in 1000s | AADT | Linear Lane Miles | Condition | Mobility | Safety & Security | Community Effects & Support | Land Use & Economic Development | Environmental Effects | Total TEC Score (2020- 2024) |
Yes | 608298 | Groveland - Community Trail | $1,985 | NA | NA | 0.50 | 1.25 | 0.67 | 1.20 | 1.00 | 0.25 | 4.87 |
No | 607540 | Boxford – section of Border to Boston Trail | $4,175 | NA | NA | 0.50 | 1.00 | 0.67 | 0.40 | 0.50 | 0.25 | 3.32 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 12
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 13
Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet
Merrimack Valley Planning Commission and MassDOT Evaluation Criteria
Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Lovejoy Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 608336
Project Cost: $7,245,000 AADT: 12,773 Distance: 2.2 Linear Lane Miles: 4.4
Condition | Score | Additional Comments | |
A. Magnitude of pavement condition improvement. | 2 | PNF indicates longitudinal & lateral pavement cracking, utility patch failure, shoving and rutting of pavement along route. | |
B. Magnitude of improvement of other infrastructure. | 2 | Current shoulder width 0' to 2', project to increase shoulder width to 4' or 5' for bikes and > safety for pe- destrians, upgrade signals, drainage improvements | |
Condition Average | 2.0 |
Mobility | Score | Additional Comments | |
A. Effect on magnitude and duration of congestion. | 3 | Adding left turn lanes at intersection at MA-133/ Lovejoy /Greenwood. Also Rt 133/ Rt 28 improvements | |
B. Effect on travel time and connectivity / access. | 2 | Widening shoulder, realigning Rt 133/ Lovejoy and add- ing left turn lanes. | |
C. Effect on other modes using the facility. | 3 | Widening shoulder for bicycles, sidewalks on both sides. | |
D. Effect on regional and local traffic. | 3 | Widening shoulder, adding left turn lanes. Additional connector I-495 to I-93. NHS roadway. | |
Mobility Average | 2.75 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 14
Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)
Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Lovejoy Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 608336
Safety and Security | Score | Additional Comments | |
A. Effect on crash rate compared to State average. | 3 | PNF Rt 133/ Lovejoy / Greenwood has a crash rate of .94, District 4 average is .78 and the arterial between two signalized intersections is 3.8, Avg. is 2.12. Have had 1 pedestrian with injuries and 1 bicycle crash. | |
B. Effect on bicycle and pedestrian safety. | 2 | Widening shoulder for bicycles and provides greater safety for pedestrians. | |
C. Effect on transportation security and evacuation routes/ | 1 | Is an NHS roadway. Is an evacuation route. | |
Safety and Security Average | 2.00 |
Community Effects and Support | Score | Additional Comments |
A. Residential effects: ROW, noise, aesthetics, cut through traffic, and other. | 2 | For the most part all within ROW. General appearance and less noise from better pavement conditions. |
B. Public, local government, legislative, and regional sup- port. | 2 | |
C. Effect on service to minority or low-income neighbor- hoods. (Title VI and EJ) | 0 | Not Title VI or EJ area. |
D. Other impacts / benefits to minority or low-income neighborhoods. (Title VI and EJ). | 0 | Not Title VI or EJ area. |
E. Effect on development and redevelopment of housing | 1 | |
Community Effects and Support Average | 1.00 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 15
Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)
Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Lovejoy Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 608336
Land Use and Economic Development | Score | Additional Comments |
A. Business effects; ROW, noise, traffic, parking, freight access, other. | 2 | Improve access to existing businesses. |
B. Sustainable development effects. Consistent with MVPGS. | 2 | Access to MVPGS Rolling Green Regional PDA. Improves transportation choice (walk/bike) for area res- idents. |
C. Consistent with regional land-use and economic devel- opment plans and PGS. | 2 | Access to MVPGS Rolling Green Regional PDA. Improves transportation choice (walk/bike) for area res- idents. |
D. Effect on job creation. | 1 | Should provide better access to Brickstone Square State PDA. |
Land Use and Economic Development Average | 1.75 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 16
Sample Project Evaluation Worksheet (Cont.)
Project: Andover - Reconstruct Rt. 133 from Lovejoy Rd to Rt. 28 Project #: 608336
Environmental Effects | Score | Additional Comments | |
A. Air quality / Climate effects. GHG Impact Description – Assumed Nominal Decrease in Emissions from Other Improvements | 2 | Adding bike lanes and sidewalks. Reducing delays at intersections. | |
B. Water quality/supply effects; wetlands effects. | 1 | There will be deep sump catch basins | |
C. Historic and cultural resources effects. | 3 | Shawsheen Village Historic District | |
D. Effect on wildlife habitat and endangered species. | 0 | Not endangered species habitat area. | |
Environmental Effects Average | 1.5 | ||
Overall Project TEC score | 11.00 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 17
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 18
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 19
This section summarizes the greenhouse gas (GHG) impacts that are anticipated to result from the projects that are included in this FFY 2020 – 2024 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP). It includes a summary of the state laws and policies that call for reducing greenhouse gas in order to mitigate global climate change, actions that respond to these state laws and policies, the role of regional planning and TIP development in reducing GHG emission and tracking these reductions, and the projected GHG emission impacts from the projects programmed in the TIP.
The Global Warming Solutions Act (GWSA), which was signed into law in August 2008, makes Massachusetts a leader in setting aggressive and enforceable GHG reduction targets, and implementing policies and initiatives to achieve these targets. In keeping with the law, on December 29, 2010 the Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs (EOEEA), in consultation with other state agencies and the public, released the Massachusetts Clean Energy and Climate Plan for 2020. In December 2014 the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) issued new regulations that require Metropolitan Planning Organizations to quantify impacts from project investments, track progress towards reductions, and consider impacts in the prioritization of project investments. The targets for overall statewide GHG emissions are:
• By 2020: 25 percent reduction below statewide 1990 GHG emission levels, and
• By 2050: 80 percent reduction below statewide 1990 GHG emission levels
The Commonwealth’s MPOs are integrally involved in supporting the GHG reductions mandated under the GWSA. The MPOs are most directly involved in helping to achieve the GHG emissions reductions through the promotion of healthy transportation modes through prioritizing and programming an appropriate balance of roadway, transit, bicycle and pedestrian investments – and assisting smart growth development patterns through the creation of a balanced multi-modal transportation system. This is realized through the transportation goals and policies espoused in the Regional Transportation Plans (RTPs),
the major projects planned in the RTPs, and the mix of new transportation projects that are
programmed and implemented through the TIPs. GHG tracking and evaluation processes
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 20
enable the MPOs to identify the anticipated GHG impacts of planned and programmed projects, and also to use GHG impacts as a criterion in prioritizing transportation projects.
It is also important to monitor and evaluate the GHG impacts of the transportation projects that are programmed in the MPOs’ TIPs. The TIPs include both the larger, regionally- significant projects from the RTPs, which are reported in the Statewide GHG report, as well as smaller projects that are not included in the RTP but that may nevertheless have
impacts on GHG emissions. The primary objective of this tracking is to enable the MPOs to evaluate expected GHG impacts of different projects and to use this information as a criterion for prioritizing and programming projects.
MassDOT has adopted spreadsheets used by MPOs to determine CMAQ eligibility and that also include CO2 impacts. The data and analysis required for these calculations is available from functional design reports that are submitted for projects that would produce a measurable GHG impact.
RTP Projects
Major capacity expansion projects are expected to have a significant impact on GHG emissions. These projects are included in each MPO’s RTP and analyzed using either the statewide model or Boston MPO’s regional model, which reflect GHG impacts. As a result, no independent TIP calculations are required.
Quantified Decrease in Emissions
For those projects that are expected to produce a measurable decrease in emissions, the approach for calculating these impacts is described below. These projects are categorized in the following manner:
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement - An intersection reconstruction or signalization project that is projected to reduce delay and congestion.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Pedestrian and Bicycle
Infrastructure - A shared-use path that enables increased walking and biking and decreased vehicle-miles traveled (VMT).
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 21
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from New/Additional Transit Service - A bus or shuttle service that enables increased transit ridership and decreased VMT.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from a Park and Ride Lot - A park-and- ride lot that enables increased transit ridership/ increased ridesharing and decreased VMT.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement
A bus replacement that directly reduces GHG emissions generated by service.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Complete Streets Improvements - Improvements to roadway networks that include the addition of bicycle and pedestrian accommodations where none were present before.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Alternative Fuel Vehicle Procurements – A vehicle procurement where alternative fuel/ advanced technology vehicles replace traditional gas or diesel vehicles.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Anti-idling Strategies – Implementation of policies such as limiting idling allowed, incorporationg anti- idling technology into fleets and using LED lights on trucks for the purpose of illuminating worksites.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bike Share Projects – A new bike share project or capacity added to existing project.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Induced Travel Projects – A project that changes roadway capacity.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Speed Reduction Programs –
Programs that reduce speed to no less than 55 miles per hour.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Transit Signal Priority Projects – A project that applies this technology to a signal intersection or along a corridor that impacts bus service.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Truck Stop Electrification Projects
– A new truck stop electrification project or capacity added to an existing project.
▪ Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Other Improvement
Quantified Increase in Emissions
Projects expected to produce a measurable increase in emissions.
No Assumed Impact/Negligible Impact on Emissions - Projects that do not change the capacity or use of a facility (e.g. roadway median barrier or retaining wall replacement, or
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 22
bridge rehabilitation/replacement that restores the bridge to its previous condition) are assumed to have no/negligible GHG impact.
Qualitative Decrease in Emissions
Projects expected to produce a minor decrease in emissions that cannot be calculated with any precision. Examples of such projects include roadway repaving, signage improvement, ITS improvement, or transit marketing/customer experience improvement.
Qualitative Increase in Emissions
Projects expected to produce a minor increase in emissions that cannot be calculated with any precision.
The following tables summarize the calculated quantitative and assumed qualitative impacts of the projects included in the regional FFYs 2020 – 2024 TIP by year.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 23
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 24
2020 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
602418 | AMESBURY- RECONSTRUCTION OF ELM STREET | $7,223,053 | Quantified | 1,336 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Com- plete Streets Project | $11,178,124 | AC yr 2 of 2. |
608027 | HAVERHILL- BRADFORD RAIL TRAIL EXTENSION, FROM ROUTE 125 TO RAILROAD STREET | $848,345 | Quantified | 422 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | $848,345 | |
605306 | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 039, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $15,305,880 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $118,786,388 | AC yr 3 of 6. |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 25
2021 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
608298 | GROVELAND- COMMUNITY TRAIL FROM MAIN STREET TO KING STREET | $2,064,255 | Quantified | 2,710 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | $2,064,255 | |
608095 | NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN ROUTE 125 (ANDOVER STREET) & STOP & SHOP DRIVEWAY | $6,813,052 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $17,399,023 | AC Yr 1 of 2 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 26
2021 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
607541 | GEORGETOWN- BOXFORD- BORDER TO BOSTON TRAIL, FROM GEORGETOWN ROAD TO WEST MAIN STREET (ROUTE 97) | $1,812,628 | Quantified | 2,667 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | $1,812,628 | |
605306 | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 039, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $15,305,880 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $118,786,388 | AC Yr 4 of 6. | |
608494 | NEWBURY- NEWBURYPORT- SALISBURY- RESURFACING AND RELATED WORK ON ROUTE 1 | $9,807,200 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $9,807,200 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 27
2022 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
608761 | HAVERHILL- INTERSECTION RECONSTRUCTION ON ROUTE 108 (NEWTON ROAD) AT ROUTE 110 (KENOZA AVENUE AND AMESBURY ROAD) | $2,099,520 | Quantified | 8,307 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improve- ment | $2,099,520 | |
608095 | NORTH ANDOVER- CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS ON ROUTE 114, BETWEEN ROUTE 125 (ANDOVER STREET) & STOP & SHOP DRIVEWAY | $8,684,626 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $17,399,023 | AC Yr 2 of 2 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 28
2022 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
605306 | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 039, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $18,203,683 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $118,786,388 | AC Yr 5 of 6. |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 29
2023 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
608788 | HAVERHILL- ROADWAY RECONSTRUCTION ON NORTH AVENUE, FROM MAIN STREET (ROUTE 125) TO PLAISTOW NH | $4,147,823 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $13,678,560 | AC Yr 1 of 2 | |
602202 | SALISBURY- RECONSTRUCTION OF ROUTE 1 (LAFAYETTE ROAD) | $7,090,517 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $7,090,517 | ||
608930 | LAWRENCE- LAWRENCE MANCHESTER RAIL CORRIDOR (LMRC) RAIL TRAIL | $15,950,704 | Quantified | 175,927 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure | $15,950,704 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 30
2023 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
607542 | GEORGETOWN- NEWBURY- BORDER TO BOSTON TRAIL, (NORTHERN GEORGETOWN TO BYFIELD SECTION) | $4,341,120 | Quantified | 15,682 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | $4,341,120 | |
605306 | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 039, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $15,305,880 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $118,786,388 | AC Yr 6 of 6. | |
TBD | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 040, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $25,198,768 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $96,000,000 | AC Yr 1 of 3. |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 31
2023 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
608494 | NEWBURY- NEWBURYPORT- SALISBURY- RESURFACING AND RELATED WORK ON ROUTE 1 | $9,807,200 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $9,807,200 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 32
2024 Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
608788 | HAVERHILL- ROADWAY RECONSTRUCTION ON NORTH AVENUE, FROM MAIN STREET (ROUTE 125) TO PLAISTOW NH | $9,530,737 | Qualitative | Qualitative Decrease in Emissions | $13,678,560 | AC Yr 2 of 2 | |
606522 | ANDOVER- BRIDGE REHABILITATION, A- 09-036, I-495 OVER ST 28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495 OVER B&M AND MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 OVER ST 28 (NB) | $17,204,394 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $113,386,056 | AC Yr 1 of 5 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 33
2024 (Cont.) Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost | Additional Information |
605304 | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 007 & H-12-025, BRIDGE STREET (SR 125) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER AND THE ABANDONED B&M RR (PROPOSED BIKEWAY) | $13,142,589 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $124,938,960 | AC Yr 1 of 5. | |
TBD | HAVERHILL- BRIDGE REPLACEMENT, H-12- 040, I-495 (NB & SB) OVER MERRIMACK RIVER | $43,180,558 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $96,000,000 | AC Yr 2 of 3. |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 34
2020 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
RTD0007680 | Preventive Maintenance | $3,323,160 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $3,323,160 | |
RTD0007681 | Non-Fixed Route ADA Pa- ra Serv | $1,653,255 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,653,255 | |
RTD0007682 | Short Range Transit Plan- ning | $100,000 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $100,000 | |
RTD0007683 | Operating Assistance | $861,550 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $861,550 | |
RTD0007687 | Replace 3 Model Yr 2007 buses delivery 2020 | $1,377,150 | Quantified | 8,166 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | $1,377,150 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 35
2020 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.) | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007695 | SGR Riverbank stabilization Construction | $1,750,330 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,750,330 | |
RDT0007696 | SGR Replace 1 model year 2013 supervisory vehicle | $46,530 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $46,530 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 36
2021 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007684 | Preventive Maintenance | $3,495,970 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $3,495,970 | |
RTD0007685 | Non-Fixed Route ADA Para Serv | $1,741,065 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,741,065 | |
RTD0007686 | Short Range Transit Plan- ning | $100,000 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $100,000 | |
RTD0007688 | Operating Assistance | $906,350 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $906,350 | |
RTD0007689 | Replace 16 Model Yr 2015 vans with new | $1,180,480 | Quantified | 32,764 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | $1,180,480 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 37
2021 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.) | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007697 | SGR Replace 1 model yr 2014 supervisory vehicle | $47,900 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $47,900 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 38
2022 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007690 | Preventive Maintenance | $3,611,335 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $3,611,335 | |
RTD0007691 | Non-Fixed Route ADA Para Serv | $1,801,630 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,801,630 | |
RTD0007692 | Short Range Transit Plan- ning | $100,000 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $100,000 | |
RTD0007693 | Operating Assistance | $936,260 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $936,260 | |
RTD0007694 | Replace Model Yr 2009 buses delivery 2022 7 of 9 | $3,417,680 | Quantified | 19,755 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | $3,417,680 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 39
2022 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.) | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0008061 | SGR Replace 2 model year 2016 supervisory vehicles | $97,740 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $97,740 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 40
2023 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007698 | Preventive Maintenance | $3,730,510 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $3,730,510 | |
RTD0007699 | Operating Assistance | $967,150 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $967,150 | |
RTD0007700 | Non-Fixed Route ADA Para Serv | $1,861,090 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,861,090 | |
RTD0007701 | Replace 2 Model Yr 2009 buses delivery 2023 | $1,005,780 | Quantified | 5,644 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | $1,005,780 |
RTD0007702 | Replace 6 model yr 2017 vans delivery 2023 | $469,620 | Qualitative | Not yet enough infor- mation to calculate | $469,620 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 41
2023 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs (Cont.) | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
RTD0007703 | Short Range Transit Plan- ning | $100,000 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $100,000 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 42
2024 Merrimack Valley Region Transit Projects GHGs | ||||||
MassDOT/ FTA Project ID | MassDOT/ FTA Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Total Cost |
Total Cost | ||||||
Preventive Maintenance | $3,853,620 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $3,853,620 | ||
Non-Fixed Route ADA Para Serv | $1,922,630 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $1,922,630 | ||
Operating Assistance | $865,320 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $865,320 | ||
Short Range Transit Plan- ning | $100,000 | Qualitative | No assumed impact/ negligible impact on emissions | $100,000 | ||
SGR Replace 2 model year 2011 buses delivery 2024 2 of 8 | $1,035,940 | Qualitative | Not yet enough infor- mation to calculate | $1,035,940 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 43
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Complete Streets Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: | 2019 | ||
MPO: | Merrimack Valley | Municipality: | Amesbury |
Project: | Project #602418 Reconstruction of Elm Street (New sidewalks from Rt 110 to Rocky Hill Road | |
and bike lanes) |
Step 1: Calculate New Walk and Bike Miles Traveled:
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A Facility Length (L): 1.1 Miles
User Input
(blank for default Default
B Types of Improvements Implemented: Both (select Pedestrian, Bicycle, or Bot
B Service Area Radius for Bicycling (RB): | 0.5 | Miles | 0.5 | |
C Service Area Radius for Walking (RW): | 0.25 | Miles | 0.25 | |
D Service Area of Community(ies) for Bicycling (SAB): | L * 2RB = SAB | 1.13 | Sq. Miles | |
E Service Area of Community(ies) for Walking (SAW): | L * 2RW = SAW | 0.565 | Sq. Miles | |
F. Land Area of Neighborhoods Served (AN): | 11.2 | Sq. Miles | ||
G Population of Neighborhoods Served (PN): | 7,137 | Persons | ||
H Population Density of Neighborhoods Served (PD): | 637 | Persons/Sq. Mile | ||
I. Population Served by Facility for Bicycling (PB): | PD * SAB = PB | 720 | Persons | |
J. Population Served by Facility for Walking (PW): | PD * SAW = PW | 360 | Persons | |
K Trips per Person per Day in Service Area (T): | 4.7 | Trips | 4.7 |
Spreadhseet Template Prepared by the Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 44
L. Baseline Bicycle Mode Share in Service Area (MSB): 0.6% Percent
M Baseline Walk Mode Share in Service Area (MSW): 4.7% Percent
N Relative Increase in Service Area Bicycle Mode Share from Improvements (BI): 30.0% Percent 30.0% O Relative Increase in Service Area Walk Mode Share from Improvements (WI): 7.5% Percent 7.5% P New Bike Trips (BT): PB * T * MSB * BI = BT 6 1-Way Trips/Day
Q New Walk Trips (WT): PW * T * MSW * WI = WT 6 1-Way Trips/Day
R Average Bike Trip Length (LB): 2.3 Miles 2.3
S.Average Walk Trip Length (LW): 0.7 Miles 0.7
T. New Bike and Walk Miles of Travel (BWM): 18 Miles per Day
Step 2: Calculate the VMT Reduction:
U Prior Drive Mode Share of New Bike and Walk Trips (MSD): 59.0% Percent 59% V.VMT Reduced per Day (VMTR): BWM * MSD = VMTR 11 Miles per Day WVMTR * Operating Days Per Year 11 * 365 = 3,942 VMTR Per Year
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH astern or Weste Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx FactorSummer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 2.095 | 338.769 |
Spreadhseet Template Prepared by the Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 45
Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Summer VOC | Summer NOx | Summer CO | Summer CO2 |
0.1 | 0.3 | 8.4 | 1,335.5 |
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Emission | Project Cost | Emission Reduction in kg per year | First year cost per kilogram | |
Summer VOC | $1,000,000 | / | 0.1 = | $8,355,241 |
Summer NOx | $1,000,000 | / | 0.3 = | $3,058,798 |
Summer CO | $1,000,000 | / | 8.4 = | $118,866 |
Summer CO2 | $1,000,000 | / | 1,335.5 = | $749 |
Spreadhseet Template Prepared by the Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 46
Georgetown - Boxford Border-to-Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: | 2019 | |
MPO: | Merrimack Valley | Municipality: Georgetown, Boxford |
Project: # 607541 Georgetown-Boxford Border to Boston Trail
Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A. Facility Length (L): 2.0 Miles
B. Service Area Radius (R): 1.0 Miles (Default = 1)
C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA 4 Sq. Miles D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T): 36.5 Sq. Miles E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA): SA / T = LA 11.0%
F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP): 16,579 Persons G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P 1,817 Persons H. Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH): 5,828 HH
I. Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS 639 HH
J. Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W): 8,647 Persons K. Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH 1.48 Persons L. Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA 948 Persons
M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 454 Persons Per Sq. Mile
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 47
Georgetown - Boxford Border-to-Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right. (BMS) 0.8% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.
http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html
O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 7 One-Way Trips
P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 12 One-Way Trips
(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. 
VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx Factor | Summer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 | 2.095 | 338.769 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 48
Georgetown - Boxford Border-to-Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Summer VOC | Summer NOx | Summer CO | Summer CO2 |
0.2 | 0.7 | 16.8 | 2,666.9 |
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Project Emission Reduction First year cost
Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram
Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO
Summer CO2
/ 0.2 = $7,840,800
/ 0.7 = $2,870,465
/ 16.8 = $111,547
/ 2,666.9 = $703
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 49
Georgetown - Newbury Border to Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY TIP YEAR: 2020
MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Georgetown, Newbury
Project: # 607542 Georgetown-Newbury Border to Boston Trail
Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A. | Facility Length (L): | 3.6 | Miles | ||
B. | Service Area Radius (R): | 1.0 | Miles | (Default = 1) | |
C. | Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): | L * 2R = SA | 7.2 | Sq. Miles | |
D. | Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T): | 36.3 | Sq. Miles | ||
E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA): SA / T = LA 19.8% | |||||
F. | Total Population of Community(ies) (TP): | 15,088 | Persons | ||
G. | Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P | 2,993 | Persons | ||
H. | Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH): | 5,808 | HH | ||
I. | Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS | 1,152 | HH | ||
J. | Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W): | 8,055 | Persons | ||
K. | Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH | 1.39 | Persons | ||
L. | Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA | 1,598 | Persons |
M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 416 Persons Per Sq. Mile
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 50
Georgetown - Newbury Border to Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the ri (BMS) 1.5% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage.
http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html
O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 24 One-Way Trips
P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 40 One-Way Trips
(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. 
VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx Factor | Summer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 | 2.095 | 338.769 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 51
Georgetown - Newbury Border to Boston Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.) Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Project Emission Reduction First year cost
Emission | Cost | in kg per year | per kilogram | |
Summer VOC | / | 1.4 = | $3,088,934 | |
Summer NOx | / | 3.8 = | $1,130,838 | |
Summer CO | / | 98.8 = | $43,945 | |
Summer CO2 | / | 15,681.6 = | $277 |
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 52
Groveland Community Trail Project # 608298 CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY TIP YEAR: 2020
MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Groveland
Project: Groveland Community Trail Project # 608298
Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A. Facility Length (L): 2.2 Miles
B. Service Area Radius (R): 1.0 Miles (Default = 1)
C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA 4.4 Sq. Miles D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T): 8.9 Sq. Miles E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA): SA / T = LA 49.4%
F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP): 6,646 Persons
G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P 3,286 Persons
H. | Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH): | 2,385 | HH |
I. | Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS | 1,179 | HH |
J. | Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W): | 3,405 | Persons |
K. | Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH | 1.43 | Persons |
L. | Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA | 1,683 | Persons |
M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 747 Persons Per Sq. Mile
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 53
Groveland Community Trail Project # 608298 CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the righ (BMS) 0.4% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage. http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html
O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 7 One-Way Trips
P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 11 One-Way Trips
(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. 
VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx Factor | Summer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 | 2.095 | 338.769 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 54
Groveland Community Trail Project # 608298 CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Summer VOC | Summer NOx | Summer CO | Summer CO2 |
0.2 | 0.7 | 17.1 | 2,709.9 |
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Project Emission Reduction First year cost
Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram
Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO Summer CO2
/ 0.2 = $11,004,874
/ 0.7 = $4,028,811
/ 17.1 = $156,560
/ 2,709.9 = $986
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 55
Haverhill Bradford Rail Trail Extension from Route 125 to Railroad St. CMAQ Air Quality Analysis
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY TIP YEAR: 2019
MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Haverhill
Project: # 608027 Bradford Rail Trail Extension from Route 125 to Railroad Street
Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A. | Facility Length (L): | 0.2 | Miles | ||
B. | Service Area Radius (R): | 1.0 | Miles | (Default = 1) | |
C. | Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): | L * 2R = SA | 0.4 | Sq. Miles | |
D. | Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T): | 33 | Sq. Miles | ||
E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA): SA / T = LA 1.2% | |||||
F. | Total Population of Community(ies) (TP): | 62,079 | Persons | ||
G. | Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P | 752 | Persons | ||
H. | Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH): | 23,781 | HH | ||
I. | Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS | 288 | HH | ||
J. | Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W): | 30,696 | Persons | ||
K. | Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH | 1.29 | Persons | ||
L. | Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA | 372 | Persons | ||
M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 1,881 Persons Per Sq. Mile |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 56
Haverhill Bradford Rail Trail Extension from Route 125 to Railroad St. CMAQ Air Quality Analysis (Cont.)
N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the ri (BMS) 3.1% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage. http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html
O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 12 One-Way Trips
P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 20 One-Way Trips
(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. 
VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx Factor | Summer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 | 2.095 | 338.769 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 57
Haverhill Bradford Rail Trail Extension from Route 125 to Railroad St. CMAQ Air Quality Analysis (Cont.)
Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Summer VOC | Summer NOx | Summer CO | Summer CO2 | |
0.0 | 0.1 | 2.7 | 422.0 |
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Project Emission Reduction First year cost
Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram
Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO Summer CO2
/ 0.0 = $31,101,222
/ 0.1 = $11,385,951
/ 2.7 = $442,461
/ 422.0 = $2,787
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 58
Haverhill - Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 at Route 110 CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Traffic Flow and Intersection Improvements
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR
MPO:
2021
Merrimack Valley
Municipality:
Haverhill
Project:
# 608761 Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 (Newton Road) at Roiute 110 (Kenoza Av & Amesbury Rd)
Step 1: Calculate Existing AM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:
Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total
Street
Name
Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
= approach delay
NB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
SB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
EB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
WB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
Total Intersection Delay/ | Seconds = | 0 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 59
Haverhill - Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 at Route 110 CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 2: Calculate Existing PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay in Seconds:
Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total
Street
Name
Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
= approach delay
NB = 0 + SB = 1,732 + EB = 2,454 + WB = 0 +
= 0 +
= 0 +
= 0 +
= 0 +
= 0 = 0
= 5,802 = 7,534
= 0 = 2,454
= 0 = 0
Total Intersection Delay/Seconds = 9,988
Step 3: The spreadsheet automatically chooses the peak hour with the longer total intersection delay for the next step in the analysis.
Peak Hour: PM
Total Intersection Delay:
9,988
Step 4: Calculate the existin PM Peak Hour Total Intersection Delay with Improvements:
Left-Turns Total Thru Total Right-Turns Total Total
Street
Name
Dir (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
+ (Vol / PHF) X delay per veh
= move. delay
= approach delay
NB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
SB | = | 2,424 | + | = | 0 + | = | 1,755 = | 4,179 |
EB | = | 2,454 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 2,454 |
WB | = | 0 | + | = | 0 + | = | 0 = | 0 |
Total Intersection Delay/ | Seconds = | 6,634 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 60
Haverhill - Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 at Route 110 CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 5: Calculate vehicle delay in hours per day:
Existing peak hour intersection delay
( Delay in seconds
( 9,988
X Hours per day) /
X 10 ) /
Seconds per hour
3600
= Delay in hours / day
= 27.7
Peak hour intersection delay w/
improvements (
X
6,634
/
10 )
3600
= 18.4
Step 6: MOVES 2014a emission factors for idling speed: AM or PM PM
2020 Summer VOC Factor grams/hour | 2020 Summer NOx Factor grams/hour | 2020 Winter CO Factor grams/hour | 2020 Summer CO2 Factor grams/hour | ||
0.249 | 0.630 | 3.569 | 3565.610 | ||
Step 7: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per day: | |||||
Winter CO | Summer CO2 | ||||
Delay in | Summer VOC Emissions | Summer NOx Emissions | Emissions | Emissions | |
Hours per Day | kilograms/day | kilograms/day | kilograms/day | kilograms/da | |
Existing Conditions | 27.7 | 0.007 | 0.017 | 0.099 | 98.929 |
With Improvements | 18.4 | 0.005 | 0.012 | 0.066 | 65.701 |
Net Change | -0.002 | -0.006 | -0.033 | -33.228 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 61
Haverhill - Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 at Route 110 CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 8: Calculate net emissions change in kilograms per year (seasonally adjusted)
Net change Avg. weekdays
Seasonal adj.
Adj. net change
per day (kg) X
per year X
factor
= in kg per year
Summer VOC Emissions -0.002 X 250 X 1.0188 = Summer NOx Emissions -0.006 X 250 X 1.0188 = Winter CO Emissions -0.033 X 250 X 0.9812 =
-0.591
-1.494
-8.158
Summer CO2 Emissions -33.228 X 250 X 1.000 -8,306.881 Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Emission
Summer
VOC
Summer
NOx
Winter
CO
Summer
CO2
Project / Cost
/
/
/
/
Adj. net change =
in kg per year
-0.591 =
-1.494 =
-8.158 =
-8,306.881 =
First year cost per kilogram
3,291,034
1,300,809
238,286
234
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 62
Lawrence Manchester Rail Corridor Rail Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet
CMAQ Air Quality Analysis Worksheet for Bicycle and Pedestrian Project
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY TIP YEAR: 2023
MPO: Merrimack Valley Municipality: Lawrence
Project: Lawrence Manchester Rail Corridor (LMRC) Rail Trail Project # 608930
Step 1: Calculate Estimated Reduction in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT):
If VMT reduction per year is known then go to Step 2B, if not proceed with Step 1 :
A. Facility Length (L): 1.5 Miles
B. Service Area Radius (R): 1.0 Miles (Default = 1)
C. Service Area of Community(ies) (SA): L * 2R = SA 2.92 Sq. Miles D. Total Land Area of Community(ies) (T): 6.93 Sq. Miles E. Service Area % of Community(ies) Land Area (LA): SA / T = LA 42.1%
F. Total Population of Community(ies) (TP): 79,337 Persons
G. Population Served by Facility (P): LA * TP = P 33,429 Persons
H. | Total Number of Households in Community(ies) (HH): | 25,759 | HH |
I. | Number of Households Served by Facility (HS): LA * HH = HS | 10,854 | HH |
J. | Total Number of Workers Residing in Community(ies) (W): | 33,261 | Persons |
K. | Workers Per household (WPHH): W / HH = WPHH | 1.29 | Persons |
L. | Workers in Service Area (WSA): HS * WPHH = WSA | 14,015 | Persons |
M. Population Density of the Service area (PD): P / SA = PD 11,448 Persons Per Sq. Mile
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 63
Lawrence Manchester Rail Corridor Rail Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
N. If the bicycle and pedestrian commuter mode share is known, enter the percentage at the right (BMS) 4.7% If not, use US Census - American Community Survey data to determine the mode share and enter the percentage. http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/guidance/estimates.html
O. Bike and Ped. Work Utilitarian Trips (BWT): WSA * BMS = BWT 659 One-Way Trips
P. Bike and Ped. Non-Work Utilitarian Trips (BNWT): BWT * 1.7 = BNWT 1,120 One-Way Trips
(Latest planning assumptions estimate non-work utilitarian trips to be 1.7 times the work utilitarian.)
If the Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction is known enter in the box to the right. 
VMTR Per Year
Note: A manual entry of the VMTR will override the calculated cell.
Step 3: MOVES 2014a Emission Factors for Unrestricted PM:
Note: Use 35 MPH as a default if average speed is not known. Speed Used: 35 MPH Eastern
2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger | 2020 Passenger |
Summer VOC Factor | Summer NOx Factor | Summer CO Factor | Summer CO2 Factor |
grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile | grams/mile |
0.030 | 0.081 | 2.095 | 338.769 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 64
Lawrence Manchester Rail Corridor Rail Trail CMAQ Air Quality Worksheet (Cont.)
Step 4: Calculate emissions reductions in kilograms per year (Seasonally Adjusted):
Summer VOC | Summer NOx | Summer CO | Summer CO2 |
15.8 | 43.1 | 1,108.2 | 175,927.3 |
Step 5: Calculate cost effectiveness (first year cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Project Emission Reduction First year cost
Emission Cost in kg per year per kilogram
Summer VOC Summer NOx Summer CO Summer CO2
/ 15.8 = $944,750
/ 43.1 = $345,867
/ 1,108.2 = $13,440
/ 175,927.3 = $85
Spreadsheet Template Prepared by Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 65
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 3 (2007) Buses with 3 (2020) Buses
CMAQ Bus Replacement Air Quality Analysis Worksheet
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: 2020 Bus Replacements
MPO: Merrimack Valley RTA: Merrimack Valley
Project #BCG0006781 - Replace 3 (2007) Buses with 3 (2020) Buses
Emission Rates in grams/mile at assumed operating speed bin of : 18 MPH (Bin 5 (17.5-22.5))
Scenario Comparison
Existing Model* = New Bus Purchase** =
Model Year
Summer
VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
(grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile)
* Please contact OTP for assistance on Existing Model emission factors
** MOVES 2014a Commercial Emission Factors - Please Specify the Following:
AM or PM: PM
Restricted or
Unrestricted
Unrestricted
Change (Buy-Base)
Calculate fleet vehicle miles per day:
Revenue miles X Deadhead = fleet miles \ operating days = fleet miles per year factor per year per year per day
104,490
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 66
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 3 (2007) Buses with 3 (2020) Buses (Cont.)
Calculate emissions change in kilograms per summer day
Change | rate change grams/mile | / 1000 g/kg | X fleet miles per day | X seasonal adj factor | = change/day in kg |
Change in Summer VOC | -0.067 | 1,000 | 342 | 1.0188 | |
Change in Summer NOx | -2.986 | 1,000 | 342 | 1.0188 | |
Change in Winter CO | -0.384 | 1,000 | 342 | 0.9812 | |
Change in Summer CO2 | -67.370 | 1,000 | 342 | 1.0000 |
Calculate emissions change in kilograms per year
Pollutant = change/day X op.days = change per in kg per year year in kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Calculate cost effectiveness (cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Pollutant Total Project / Project Life / reduction per = annual cost
Cost in years year in kg per kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Template prepared by the Offic of Transportation Plannning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 67
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 16 (2015) Vans with 16 (2021) Vans
CMAQ Bus Replacement Air Quality Analysis Worksheet
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: 2021 Bus Replacements
MPO: Merrimack Valley RTA: Merrimack Valley
Project #BCG0006784 - Replace 16 (2015) Vans with 16 (2021) vans
Emission Rates in grams/mile at assumed operating speed bin of : 18 MPH (Bin 5 (17.5-22.5))
Scenario Comparison
Summer
VOC Summer NOx Winter CO
Summer
CO2
Existing Model* = New Bus Purchase** =
Model Year
(grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile)
* Please contact OTP for assistance on Existing Model emission factors
** MOVES 2014a Commercial Emission Factors - Please Specify the Following:
AM or PM: PM
Restricted or
Unrestricted
Unrestricted
Change (Buy-Base)
Calculate fleet vehicle miles per day:
Revenue miles X Deadhead = fleet miles operating days = fleet miles per year factor per year per year per day
436,096
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 68
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 16 (2015) Vans with 16 (2021) Vans (Cont.) Calculate emissions change in kilograms per summer day
Change
Change in Summer VOC -0.005 1,000 | 1,397 | 1.0188 | |
Change in Summer NOx -0.033 1,000 | 1,397 | 1.0188 | |
Change in Winter CO -1.421 1,000 | 1,397 | 0.9812 | |
Change in Summer CO2 -65.331 1,000 | 1,397 | 1.0000 | |
Calculate emissions change in kilograms per year | |||
Pollutant | = change/day in kg | X op.days per year | = change per year in kg |
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2 |
Calculate cost effectiveness (cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Pollutant Total Project / Project Life / reduction per = annual cost
Cost in years year in kg per kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Template prepared by the Office of Transportation Plannning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 69
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 7 (2009) Buses with 7 (2022) Buses
CMAQ Bus Replacement Air Quality Analysis Worksheet
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: 2022 Bus Replacements
MPO: Merrimack Valley RTA: Merrimack Valley
Project #BCG0006791 - Replace 7 (2009) Buses with 7 (2022) Buses
Emission Rates in grams/mile at assumed operating speed bin of : 18 MPH (Bin 5 (17.5-22.5))
Scenario Comparison
Summer
VOC Summer NOx Winter CO
Summer
CO2
Existing Model* = New Bus Purchase** =
Model Year
(grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile)
* Please contact OTP for assistance on Existing Model emission factors
** MOVES 2014a Commercial Emission Factors - Please Specify the Following:
AM or PM: PM
Restricted or
Unrestricted
Unrestricted
Change (Buy-Base)
Calculate fleet vehicle miles per day:
Revenue miles X Deadhead = fleet miles / operating days = fleet miles per year factor per year per year per day
243,810
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 70
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 7 (2009) Buses with 7 (2022) Buses (Cont.) Calculate emissions change in kilograms per summer day
Change rate change / 1000 X fleet miles X seasonal = change/day grams/mile g/kg per day adj factor in kg
Change in Summer VOC -0.067 1,000 799 1.0188
Change in Summer NOx -2.986 1,000 799 1.0188
Change in Winter CO -0.384 1,000 799 0.9812
Change in Summer CO2 -69.850 1,000 799 1.0000
Calculate emissions change in kilograms per year
Pollutant = change/day X op.days = change per in kg per year year in kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Calculate cost effectiveness (cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Pollutant Total Project / Project Life / reduction per = annual cost
Cost in years year in kg per kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Template prepared by the Office of Transportation Plannning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 71
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 2 (2009) Buses with 2 (2023) Buses
CMAQ Bus Replacement Air Quality Analysis Worksheet
FILL IN SHADED BOXES ONLY
TIP YEAR: 2023 Bus Replacements
MPO: Merrimack Valley RTA: Merrimack Valley
Project #RTD0007135 - Replace 2 (2009) Buses with 2 (2023) Buses
Emission Rates in grams/mile at assumed operating speed bin of: 18 MPH (Bin 5 (17.5-22.5))
Scenario Comparison
Summer
VOC Summer NOx Winter CO
Summer
CO2
Existing Model* = New Bus Purchase** =
Model Year
(grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile) (grams/mile)
* Please contact OTP for assistance on Existing Model emission factors
** MOVES 2014a Commercial Emission Factors - Please Specify the Following:
AM or PM: PM
Restricted or
Unrestricted
Unrestricted
Change (Buy-Base)
Calculate fleet vehicle miles per day:
Revenue miles X Deadhead = fleet miles / operating days = fleet miles per year factor per year per year per day
69,660
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 72
Merrimack Valley RTA Replace 2 (2009) Buses with 2 (2023) Buses (Cont.) Calculate emissions change in kilograms per summer day
Change rate change / 1000 X fleet miles X seasonal = change/day grams/mile g/kg per day adj factor in kg
Change in Summer VOC -0.067 1,000 228 1.0188
Change in Summer NOx -2.986 1,000 228 1.0188
Change in Winter CO -0.384 1,000 228 0.9812
Change in Summer CO2 -69.850 1,000 228 1.0000
Calculate emissions change in kilograms per year
Pollutant = change/day X op.days = change per in kg per year year in kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Calculate cost effectiveness (cost per kg of emissions reduced)
Pollutant Total Project / Project Life / reduction per = annual cost
Cost in years year in kg per kg
Summer VOC Summer NOx Winter CO Summer CO2
Template prepared by the Office of Transportation Planning Updated March 2016
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 73
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 74
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 75
Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary | |||||||
Mass DOT/ Project ID | MassDOT Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Additional Description | Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward) |
606503 | NEWBURYPORT CLIPPER CITY RAIL TRAIL ALONG THE CITY BRANCH (PHASE II) | $4,061,158 | Quantified | 34,996 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | Advertised 9/19/2015 Notice to Proceed 4/1/2016 | 2016 |
606161 | HAVERHILL- IMPROVEMENTS ON MAIN STREET (ROUTE 125) | $3,635,519 | Quantified | 16,491 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improve- ment | Advertised 9/17/2016 Notice to Proceed 4/12/2017 | 2017 |
607573 | HAVERHILL- RECONSTRUCTION ON ROUTE 97 (BROADWAY), FROM SILVER BIRCH LANE TO RESEARCH DRIVE | $6,526,912 | Quantified | 41,800 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improve- ment | Advertised 5/13/2017 Notice to Proceed 2/9/2018 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 76
Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary (Cont.) | |||||||
Mass DOT/ Project ID | MassDOT Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Im- pact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Additional Description | Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward) |
604585 | FLEX TO FTA FOR MVRTA NEW BUS UPGRADE TO CLEANER FUEL BUSES | $645,840 | Quantified | 26,343 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | Flexed to FTA | 2017 |
605020 | SALISBURY- MULTI- USE TRAIL EXTENSION (BORDERS TO BOSTON TRAIL), INCLUDES NEW BRIDGE S-02-004 AND BOARDWALK (S-02- 012) (BYX) | $5,918,500 | Quantified | 18,631 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedestrian Infra- structure | Advertised 8/25/2018 Contract Awarded 12/12/18 Notice to Proceed 1/18/19 | 2018 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 77
Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Highway Projects GHG Tracking Summary (Cont.) | |||||||
Mass DOT/ Project ID | MassDOT Project Description | Total Pro- grammed Funds | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Additional Description | Fiscal Year of Contract Award (2015 and forward) |
607737 | AMESBURY- SALISBURY- TRAIL CONNECTOR @ I-95 | $2,574,805 | Quantified | 3,972 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bicycle and Pedes- trian Infrastructure | Advertised 9/15/2018 Awaiting Contract Award | |
606159 | NORTH ANDOVER- INTERSECTION & SIGNAL IMPROVEMENTS AT ROUTE 125 & MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE | $5,446,662 | Quantified | 482,727 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Traffic Operational Improvement | Advertised 1/12/2019 Bids due 4/17/2019 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 78
Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Transit Projects GHG Tracking Summary | ||||||||
FTA Activity Line Item | Transit Agency | Project Description | Total Cost | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Additional Descrip- tion | Fiscal Year Pro- grammed (2015 and forward) |
MVRTA | Purchase – Re- placement Vans 11 Model Year 2009 Delivery 2015 | $627,000 | Quantified | 41,814 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | 2015 | ||
111202 | MVRTA | Replace 10 of 17 Model Year 2004 Transit Buses with new buses (Delivery 2016) | $4,200,000 | Quantified | 12,557 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | 2015 | |
111215 | MVRTA | Replace 5 Model Year 2011 Para- transit Vehicles (De- livery 2016) | $320,000 | Quantified | 15,992 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | 2016 | |
111202 | MVRTA | Replace 7 MY 2004 Transit Buses with new buses | $2,989,000 | Quantified | 18,271 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | 2017 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 79
Merrimack Valley Region MPO TIP Completed Transit Projects GHG Tracking Summary (Cont.) | ||||||||
FTA Activity Line Item | Transit Agency | Project Description | Total Cost | GHG Analysis Type | GHG CO2 Impact (kg/yr) | GHG Impact Description | Additional Descrip- tion | Fiscal Year Pro- grammed (2015 and forward) |
111202 | MVRTA | Replace 6 Model Year 2004 Buses (Delivery 2018) | $2,689,500 | Quantified | 15,661 | Quantified Decrease in Emissions from Bus Replacement | 2018 |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 80
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 81
MVMPO List of Commonly Used Acronyms | ||
A | AADT | Average Annual Daily Traffic |
AASHTO | American Association of State Highway Transpor- tation Officials | |
ABP | MassDOT Accelerated Bridge Program | |
AC | Advance Construction | |
ADA | Americans with Disabilities Act (1990) | |
ADT | Average Daily Traffic | |
ARRA | American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (of 2009) | |
AQ | Air Quality | |
B | B to B | Border to Boston Rail Trail |
BR, BR-On, BR-Off | Bridge Rehabilitation or Replacement (On- or Off- National Highway System) | |
C | (C) | Type of Project = Capital Improvement |
3C | Continuing, Comprehensive and Coordinated (Transportation Planning) | |
CAAA | Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 | |
CFR | Code of Federal Regulations | |
CIP | Capital Investment Plan | |
CLF | Conservation Law Foundation | |
CMAQ | Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improve- ment Program | |
CMP | Congestion Management Process | |
CMR | Code of Massachusetts Regulations | |
CNG | Compressed Natural Gas | |
CO | Carbon Monoxide | |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 82
D | DEP | Department of Environmental Protection |
DOT | Department of Transportation | |
DPW | Department of Public Works | |
E | EB | Eastbound |
EIR | Environmental Impact Report | |
EIS | Environmental Impact Statement | |
EJ | Environmental Justice | |
ENF | Environmental Notification Form | |
E.O. | Executive Order (of the Governor of the Com- monwealth) | |
EPA | U.S. Environmental Protection Agency | |
F | FA | Federal-Aid |
FAPRO | Federal Aid Program Reimbursement Office | |
FAST Act | Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act legis- lation signed into law December 4, 2015 | |
FHWA | Federal Highway Administration | |
FTA | Federal Transit Administration | |
FY | (State) Fiscal Year | |
FFY | Federal Fiscal Year | |
G | GANs | Grant Anticipation Notes |
GHG | Greenhouse Gas | |
H | HPP | USDOT High Priority Project |
HSIP | Highway Safety Improvement Program |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 83
I | IM | Interstate Maintenance |
ITS | Intelligent Transportation System | |
ISTEA | Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act of 1991 | |
L | LEP | Limited English Proficiency |
LOS | Level of Service | |
LTA | Local Technical Assistance | |
M | (M) | Type of project = Maintenance |
MAP-21 | Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century legis- lation signed into law July 6, 2012 | |
MassDOT | Massachusetts Department of Transportation | |
MCAD | Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination | |
MEPA | Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act | |
M.G.L. | Massachusetts General Laws | |
MOA | Memorandum of Agreement | |
MOD | Massachusetts Office on Disabilities | |
MOU | Memorandum of Understanding | |
MPO | Metropolitan Planning Organization | |
MVMPO | Merrimack Valley Metropolitan Planning Organiza- tion | |
MVPC | Merrimack Valley Planning Commission | |
MVPGS | Merrimack Valley Priority Growth Strategy | |
MVRTA | Merrimack Valley Regional Transit Authority | |
N | (N) | Type of project = other, not capital expense, or oper- ating expense, but other such as planning or design |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 84
NAAQS | National Ambient Air Quality Standards | |
NARC | National Association of Regional Councils | |
NB | Northbound | |
NEPA | National Environmental Policy Act | |
NFA | Non-Federal Aid | |
NHS | National Highway System | |
NMCOG | Northern Middlesex Council of Governments | |
NOx | Nitrogen Oxide | |
NPRM | Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (Federal Register) | |
O | (O) | Type of Project = Operating Expense |
O&M | Operations and Maintenance | |
P | PCI | Pavement Condition Index |
PDA | Priority Development Area | |
PL | (Metropolitan) Planning Funds | |
PMS | Pavement Management System | |
PPP | Public Participation Plan | |
PRC | (MassDOT) Project Review Committee | |
PSAC | Project Selection Advisory Council | |
PS&E | The Plans, Specifications and Estimate to be used by contractors to bid on construction proposals | |
R | RGGI | Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative |
ROW | Right-of-Way | |
RPA | Regional Planning Agency | |
RPMS | Regional Pavement Management System | |
RTA | Regional Transit Authority | |
RTP | Regional Transit Plan | |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 85
S | SAFETEA-LU | Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transporta- tion Equity Act: A Legacy for Users |
SB | Southbound | |
SD | Structurally Deficient | |
SGR | State of Good Repair | |
SIP | State (Air Quality) Implementation Plan | |
SOV | Single Occupancy Vehicle | |
SPR | Statewide Planning and Research Funds | |
STBG | Surface Transportation Block Grant Program | |
STIP | Statewide Transportation Improvement Program | |
STP | Surface Transportation Program | |
T | TA | Transportation Alternatives |
TAM | Transit Asset Management | |
TAP | Transportation Alternatives Program | |
TCSP | Transportation and Community System Preserva- tion Grant Program | |
TDM | Transportation Demand Management | |
TEA-21 | Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century | |
TEC | Transportation Project Evaluation Criteria | |
TERM score | Transit Economic Requirements Model score used to rate transit facility conditions | |
TIP | Transportation Improvement Program | |
TMA | Transportation Management Area | |
TMC | Turning Movement Count | |
TOD | Transit-Oriented Development | |
TRB | Transportation Research Board | |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 86
U | ULB | Useful Life Benchmark |
UPWP | Unified Planning Work Program | |
USDOT | U.S. Department of Transportation | |
V | V/C | Volume/Capacity Ratio |
VMT | Vehicle Miles Traveled | |
VOC | Volatile Organic Compound | |
W | WB | Westbound |
Massachusetts Executive Orders | ||
EO | 526 | Nondiscrimination, Diversity, Equal Employment Opportunity and Affirmative Action |
EO | 12898 | Environmental Justice in Minority and Low-Income Populations, February 1994 |
EO | 13166 | Improving Access to Programs (and Services) for persons with limited English Proficiency |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 87
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 88
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 89
Map Number | Project Number | City/Town | Project Description |
602418 | Amesbury | Amesbury – Reconstruction of Elm Street | |
606522 | Andover | Andover- Bridge Rehabilitation, A-09-036, I-495 over St 28 (SB), A-09-037, I-495 over B&M and MBTA, A-09-041, I-495 over St 28 (NB) | |
607541 | Georgetown- Boxford | Georgetown – Boxford Border to Boston Trail from Georgetown Road to West Main Street (Route 97) | |
607542 | Georgetown- Newbury | Georgetown– Newbury Border to Boston Trail (Northern Georgetown to Byfield Section) | |
608298 | Groveland | Groveland- Groveland Community Trail, from Main Street to King Street | |
608027 | Haverhill | Haverhill- Bradford Rail Trail Extension, from Route 125 to Railroad Street | |
RTD - 7695 | MVRTA | SGR Riverbank Stabilization Construction | |
605306 | Haverhill | Haverhill – Bridge Replacement, H-12- 039, I-495 (NB & SB) over Merrimack River | |
605304 | Haverhill | Haverhill- Bridge Replacement, H-12-007 & H-12-025, Bridge Street (SR 125) over Merrimack River and the Abandoned B&M RR (Proposed Bikeway) |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 90
Map Number | Project Number | City/Town | Project Description |
608761 | Haverhill | Haverhill – Intersection Reconstruction on Route 108 (Newton Road) at Route 110 (Kenoza Avenue and Amesbury Road) | |
608788 | Haverhill | Haverhill – Roadway Reconstruction on North Avenue, from Main Street (Route 125) to Plaistow NH | |
608930 | Lawrence | Lawrence - Lawrence Manchester Rail Corridor (LMRC) Rail Trail | |
608494 | Newbury / Newburyport / Salisbury | Resurfacing of Route 1 | |
608095 | North Andover | North Andover- Corridor Improvements on Route 114, between Route 125 (Andover Street) & Stop & Shop driveway | |
602202 | Salisbury | Salisbury – Reconstruction of Route 1 (Lafayette Road) | |
TBD | Haverhill | Haverhill – Bridge Replacement, H-12-040, I-495 (NB & SB) over Merrimack River |
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 91
Page intentionally left blank.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 92
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 93
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 94
Response: Changes made.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 95
The Town of Groveland sent an email confirming that the Groveland Community Trail Project
was on track to be ready for FFY 2021 and they provided more details about the project’s
progress.
Final FFYs 2020-2024 MVMPO TIP Appendix May 2019 96